Fan control and feedback
-
Hi there.
I'm currently trying to add fan control and monitoring to one of my projects. I'm using a CPU PWM fan with 4 wires.
I can control the speed of the fan and read the rotation speed.Currently the fan is registered as a S_DIMMER where it sends its speed back to the controller (domoticz) as a V_VAR1. The nice thing being that if later on I decide to add an additional fan I can use V_VAR2, etc... Unfortunately domoticz seems to ignore V_VAR messages, I can't find a way to graph them or set units.
As a workaround I don't see any sensor type that could be used to send RPMs either.
It's unclear to me if I should ask for another sensor type in MyS such as a RPM/frequency/speed one or if it would be better to keep V_VAR and ask for a way to graph them in the controller.
Is there an official position on this kind of issue, being compatible with all controllers?
-
Hi there.
I'm currently trying to add fan control and monitoring to one of my projects. I'm using a CPU PWM fan with 4 wires.
I can control the speed of the fan and read the rotation speed.Currently the fan is registered as a S_DIMMER where it sends its speed back to the controller (domoticz) as a V_VAR1. The nice thing being that if later on I decide to add an additional fan I can use V_VAR2, etc... Unfortunately domoticz seems to ignore V_VAR messages, I can't find a way to graph them or set units.
As a workaround I don't see any sensor type that could be used to send RPMs either.
It's unclear to me if I should ask for another sensor type in MyS such as a RPM/frequency/speed one or if it would be better to keep V_VAR and ask for a way to graph them in the controller.
Is there an official position on this kind of issue, being compatible with all controllers?
@emc2 As the V_VAR types have no specific meaning Domoticz cannot handle them in a structured way.
For a fan I would choose a PERCENTAGE type and let Domoticz treat it as (the new) Selector switch. You can even choose a fan icon for it.
V_VAR should be used for (temporary) storage of variables only. -
@emc2 As the V_VAR types have no specific meaning Domoticz cannot handle them in a structured way.
For a fan I would choose a PERCENTAGE type and let Domoticz treat it as (the new) Selector switch. You can even choose a fan icon for it.
V_VAR should be used for (temporary) storage of variables only.@AWI
Thanks for the heads up. The selector is an option, but the sliding ruler of the domoticz interface is actually more suitable in my current use. I was looking at the S_HVAC that could have worked too, but the slider is nicer for fine tuning. I wish I could have a fan icon with the Dimmer option in domoticz. Control by itself is working fine.I guess V_VAR is not adapted for that then. Too bad.
I'm thinking of trying a S_DISTANCE using V_UNIT_PREFIX (RPM) and V_DISTANCE to send the values. It's kind of dirty but well.
Maybe using V_UNIT_PREFIX with a S_CUSTOM sensor and sending V_LEVEL for the values is what seems almost the most intuitive, but it seems we can't do that.
Any idea of a workaround solution using current sensors that could be accepted by the controller? -
@AWI
Thanks for the heads up. The selector is an option, but the sliding ruler of the domoticz interface is actually more suitable in my current use. I was looking at the S_HVAC that could have worked too, but the slider is nicer for fine tuning. I wish I could have a fan icon with the Dimmer option in domoticz. Control by itself is working fine.I guess V_VAR is not adapted for that then. Too bad.
I'm thinking of trying a S_DISTANCE using V_UNIT_PREFIX (RPM) and V_DISTANCE to send the values. It's kind of dirty but well.
Maybe using V_UNIT_PREFIX with a S_CUSTOM sensor and sending V_LEVEL for the values is what seems almost the most intuitive, but it seems we can't do that.
Any idea of a workaround solution using current sensors that could be accepted by the controller? -
@AWI I discovered it the hard way tonight. Lot of "Unknown sensor type" in my domoticz log.
I have it working by declaring it as a distance, pressure etc. It's really dirty but at least for know I can track my RPMs. I guess I will try to poke around on the domoticz forums this week end to see if there is something cooking on their side.
Thanks!
