Gateway question
-
So I realize that I need to do some more shopping. But to avoid to end up short of things again I thought I'd ask what to buy.
I need NRF for gateway. Is there any benefit of buying one with an antenna for better reception? Or should I just buy a pack of 10 ordinary and that would be enough for the gateway too?
What kind of Arduinos to use for their nodes? Arduino Pro Mini? Or is Sensebender a better solution? I'm just looking for a decent starting ground to be able to create a few nodes. Don't really have any plans for more nodes right now, just for future ideas.
Anything else that is good to have?
-
As @tbowmo said, you can connect sensors directly to the gateway (esp8266 in your case). No need for nrf radio.
More information: https://forum.mysensors.org/topic/4066/ethernet-gateway-working-as-sensor-node-it-s-possible/
So I am really trying to understand how this works, and unfortunately the links don't help that much. Feeling really stupid.
Either it is possible but no one has done it or I don't understand how it has been done. But after reading everything I can find I still don't understand how it works.
All the examples about gateways include a NRF module, with exception of having the gateway directly on a ESP8266. But then you get very limited with I/O ports.
I would like to have a Arduino as a gateway, and instead of using NRF for communication it should use a ESP8266. No sketch or anything on the ESP, only used for communication. All sensors and things should be connected to the Arduino.
What am I missing?
-
So I am really trying to understand how this works, and unfortunately the links don't help that much. Feeling really stupid.
Either it is possible but no one has done it or I don't understand how it has been done. But after reading everything I can find I still don't understand how it works.
All the examples about gateways include a NRF module, with exception of having the gateway directly on a ESP8266. But then you get very limited with I/O ports.
I would like to have a Arduino as a gateway, and instead of using NRF for communication it should use a ESP8266. No sketch or anything on the ESP, only used for communication. All sensors and things should be connected to the Arduino.
What am I missing?
@raptorjr I don't know if anyone has done it before but it might be possible to use rs485 between the esp and the Arduino. See the example at https://github.com/mysensors/MySensors/blob/development/examples/GatewaySerialRS485/GatewaySerialRS485.ino
Or ditch the esp and connect the arduino to a computer directly
-
This will be far more complicated than I have knowledge for right now.
I just think it is kind of strange that the combination of a Wifi enabled controller and Wifi enabled node is not supported. For me as a beginner it is just another media for communication.
-
This will be far more complicated than I have knowledge for right now.
I just think it is kind of strange that the combination of a Wifi enabled controller and Wifi enabled node is not supported. For me as a beginner it is just another media for communication.
@raptorjr wifi-enabled nodes are supported, in the ways described earlier.
If you want to connect an Arduino to a gateway by wire, that is also supported by using rs485 serial communication.
Is there another wired protocol between nodes and gateway that you would like to use instead of serial communication?
-
@raptorjr wifi-enabled nodes are supported, in the ways described earlier.
If you want to connect an Arduino to a gateway by wire, that is also supported by using rs485 serial communication.
Is there another wired protocol between nodes and gateway that you would like to use instead of serial communication?
@mfalkvidd
Since I have ordered a bunch of NRF cards this will not be a problem in a few weeks. Just trying to understand and learn things while waiting.I would like to make a node that consist of a arduino nano with sensors attached, and a ESP connected to the arduino for communication. I would then like to add that node to Domoticz running on a Pi3 with Wifi.
-
@mfalkvidd
Since I have ordered a bunch of NRF cards this will not be a problem in a few weeks. Just trying to understand and learn things while waiting.I would like to make a node that consist of a arduino nano with sensors attached, and a ESP connected to the arduino for communication. I would then like to add that node to Domoticz running on a Pi3 with Wifi.
-
@raptorjr that should be possibe by using rs485 serial communication between the esp and the Arduino. Rs485 supports up to 32 connected Arduinos from what I have understood (I have not had any use for rs485 though so I have not tried it)
@mfalkvidd
Maybe I'm starting to understand now =) The RS485 gateway sketch on the Arduino, and then I need a sketch on the ESP that transfer the serial commands from the Arduino through Wifi? -
Not quite.
The device that converts between one protocol (rs485, nrf, rfm) and another protocol (serial, wifi, wired ethernet) is called a gateway in MySensors vocabulary.
So the esp would be a gateway. The esp talks wifi to the controller and rs485 to the Arduinos.
-
The naming in the MySensors examples can be a bit confusing though.
GatewaySerialRS485 uses rs485 to talk to sensors and (rs232) serial to talk to the controller
GatewayESP8266 Uses nrf or rfm to talk to sensors and wireless ethernet to talk to the controller
GatewayW5100 Uses nrf or rfm to talk to sensors and wired ethernet to talk to the controller -
The naming in the MySensors examples can be a bit confusing though.
GatewaySerialRS485 uses rs485 to talk to sensors and (rs232) serial to talk to the controller
GatewayESP8266 Uses nrf or rfm to talk to sensors and wireless ethernet to talk to the controller
GatewayW5100 Uses nrf or rfm to talk to sensors and wired ethernet to talk to the controller -
Not quite.
The device that converts between one protocol (rs485, nrf, rfm) and another protocol (serial, wifi, wired ethernet) is called a gateway in MySensors vocabulary.
So the esp would be a gateway. The esp talks wifi to the controller and rs485 to the Arduinos.
-
@mfalkvidd
So there isn't really any combination that would work for me?I would need a ESP8266Gateway that would talk RS485 to my Arduino with all the sensors?
@raptorjr no here is no example. It might be really easy to make one though. There is very little difference between the sketches. This might be all that's needed to create a rs485 to wifi:
Enable RS485 transport layer #define MY_RS485 // Define this to enables DE-pin management on defined pin #define MY_RS485_DE_PIN 2 // Set RS485 baud rate to use #define MY_RS485_BAUD_RATE 9600 #define MY_GATEWAY_ESP8266 #define MY_ESP8266_SSID "MySSID" #define MY_ESP8266_PASSWORD "MyVerySecretPassword" -
You might want to join forces with @hausinger who wanted to build the same thing just a few days ago at the end of this thread: https://forum.mysensors.org/topic/1947/rs485-rs232-serial-transport-class-for-mysensors-org/94
https://forum.mysensors.org/topic/3451/serial-gateway-with-several-sensors-connected-to-it/10 explains the main difference between rs232 and rs485
-
for side note, I just would like to confirm that esp8266(nodemcu in my case) mqtt client gw works ok with rfm69 ;) with a nice rgb led using indication api :) but I use serial gw as regular.
I'm not using rs485 sorry :disappointed: unfortunately there are some work I think to make what you want working (and that would need software serial stuff, not the greatest thing imho but that's useful sometimes..)
A bit too bad that you need to use wifi with rs485..but I guess you have your reason ;) I just mean with rs485 you can have long wire so you could reach a simple rs485 gw connected to controller, but maybe you can't reach your controller with wire? -
Well, it is not so much about having to use a wire although I think that when possible things should be wireless. It is more about that I don't have a NRF card but only a ESP card and I would like to get something working since it takes a few weeks to get the NRF cards.
Arduino+NRF can be used as a node, Arduino+ESP can't. Wasn't even thinking that no one had done that before and that there wasn't any support for it. The only difference in my mind is that the ESP have to be configured to connect to a wireless network first. After that there shouldn't have to be any difference with the communication. But maybe the example above could work?
But as I said, I have no experience about this and just got my first Arduino a few days ago, so I have no clue about these things.
-
for side note, I just would like to confirm that esp8266(nodemcu in my case) mqtt client gw works ok with rfm69 ;) with a nice rgb led using indication api :) but I use serial gw as regular.
I'm not using rs485 sorry :disappointed: unfortunately there are some work I think to make what you want working (and that would need software serial stuff, not the greatest thing imho but that's useful sometimes..)
A bit too bad that you need to use wifi with rs485..but I guess you have your reason ;) I just mean with rs485 you can have long wire so you could reach a simple rs485 gw connected to controller, but maybe you can't reach your controller with wire?
