RFM69 ATC not working?

TSD

@mfalkvidd
My code now looks pretty much the same as yours, except for the OTA stuff. But I don't see gateway messages in Domoticz. The node shows up with all its measurements.

#define MY_DEBUG_VERBOSE_GATEWAY
#include <MySensors.h>

MyMessage msgRSSI(1,V_LEVEL);

#define ARDUINO 100
// This space is intended to be used to include arduino libraries

#undef ARDUINO

void setup()
{
        // Setup locally attached sensors
}

void presentation()
{
        // Present locally attached sensors here
present(1,S_SOUND);

}

void loop()
{
        // Send locally attached sensors data here
}

void receive(const MyMessage &message)
{
  int16_t rssiReceive = RFM69_getReceivingRSSI();
  if (message.sender == 1 ) {
    send(msgRSSI.set(rssiReceive,0));
  }
}

Is the gateway supposed to show up as a measurement? Any idea why that doesn't happen?

TSD

@gohan
I added your code to my node. It gives exactly the same results as my own code. What kind of node are you using? Are you using the HW or W version of the RFM69?

gohan

it works the same, of course if you have a HW version you will see TX power % lower compared to a W module. I am not using those functions on the gateway because they are actually more node related

TSD

@gohan @mfalkvidd
I think it is related to the Raspberry Pi implementation of MySensors. If I use an Arduino/RFM69 gateway, the RSSI is as expected. At close range, the power drops to the minimum possible level and the RSSI is strong. I noticed that the interrupt pin is toggled during communication, see picture below (orange is node current, blue is gateway interrupt).
0_1540320711757_arduino-gateway_node-current_gw-interrupt.bmp

If I use the Raspberry gateway (with origin/development-3.0.0 MySensors), I get the following result (orange is node current, yellow is gateway interrupt). The same result is obtained with MySensors 2.3.0 (origin/master). I couldn't get the origin/development version to compile. It gives an error about MY_DEBUGDEVICE.
0_1540320810723_raspberry-gateway_node-current_gw-interrupt.bmp
Apart from the much higher node current (and worse RSSI), the interrupt pin is always high and not toggled.

Are you guys using a Raspberry gateway, or an Arduino gateway?

I haven't had time to dig into to the MySensors code further, but does any of you know if this could be the problem?

mfalkvidd

@tsd nice work. I'm using an esp8266 gateway but I don't use atc.

gohan

I am using raspberry with both nrf24 and rfm69 gateway on it, but I am still version 2.2.0

diogoc

I have problems too with the linux gateway

link text

TSD

@gohan
I just tried with the node on MySensors 2.2.0, but I get the same result. I cannot get the gateway to compile with 2.2.0, I get the following errors:

In file included from ./MySensors.h:49:0,
                 from examples_linux/mysgw.cpp:83:
./drivers/RFM69/new/RFM69_new.cpp: In function ‘bool RFM69_initialise(uint32_t)’:
./MyConfig.h:716:26: error: ‘DEFAULT_RFM69_IRQ_NUM’ was not declared in this scope
 #define MY_RFM69_IRQ_NUM DEFAULT_RFM69_IRQ_NUM
                          ^
./drivers/RFM69/new/RFM69_new.cpp:230:18: note: in expansion of macro ‘MY_RFM69_IRQ_NUM’
  attachInterrupt(MY_RFM69_IRQ_NUM, RFM69_interruptHandler, RISING);
                  ^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
In file included from ./MySensors.h:347:0,
                 from examples_linux/mysgw.cpp:83:
./hal/transport/MyTransportRFM69.cpp: In function ‘uint8_t transportReceive(void*)’:
./hal/transport/MyTransportRFM69.cpp:80:54: error: ‘RFM69_recv’ was not declared in this scope
  return RFM69_recv((uint8_t*)data, MAX_MESSAGE_LENGTH);
                                                      ^
In file included from ./MySensors.h:343:0,
                 from examples_linux/mysgw.cpp:83:
./drivers/RFM69/new/RFM69_new.cpp: At global scope:
./drivers/RFM69/new/RFM69_new.cpp:749:12: warning: ‘void RFM69_encrypt(const char*)’ defined but not used [-Wunused-function]
 LOCAL void RFM69_encrypt(const char *key)
            ^~~~~~~~~~~~~
./drivers/RFM69/new/RFM69_new.cpp:599:12: warning: ‘void RFM69_ATCmode(bool, int16_t)’ defined but not used [-Wunused-function]
 LOCAL void RFM69_ATCmode(const bool onOff, const int16_t targetRSSI)
            ^~~~~~~~~~~~~
./drivers/RFM69/new/RFM69_new.cpp:340:15: warning: ‘uint8_t RFM69_receive(uint8_t*, uint8_t)’ defined but not used [-Wunused-function]
 LOCAL uint8_t RFM69_receive(uint8_t *buf, const uint8_t maxBufSize)

Do you have the gateway running with 2.2.0? And ATC works for the RFM69?

TSD

@mfalkvidd
And if you turn on ATC? Does that work? Are you on 2.3.0?

mfalkvidd

@tsd I don't know which version I am using. I'm currently travelling so I can't check easily.

TSD

@scalz
I found your name in the Raspberry Pi MySensor driver files. Would you happen to know why the RSSI measurement for a RPi gateway doesn't work? I'm having trouble getting ATC to work with my RPi gateway. It works well with an Arduino gateway.

gohan

I still don't understand the need to measure RSSI on gateway...

TSD

@gohan
I couldn't get the RSSI measurement on the gateway to work, so I'm not doing that.

I want to get ATC to work. As ATC uses RSSI to optimize power, a correct RSSI measurement (on the node) is needed. ATC (and so the RSSI measurement) works well on an Arduino gateway, but not on a RPi.

As I don't have a software background and am still newish to MySensors, I'm hoping someone on the forum knows what to do. In the meantime, I'll keep digging myself :)

gohan

But do the nodes increase power as they are moved farther away from the gateway?

mfalkvidd

@gohan as TSD has already explained earlier in this thread, the ATC nodes always transmit on max power when using the raspberry pi gateway, regardless of distance.

prelektr

Was there any follow up to this issue?

I can confirm that ATC does not work using Rpi gateway. Well, it kind of works when you set very low MY_RFM69_ATC_TARGET_RSSI_DBM. I tried -100dBm and then the node is finally decreasing TX power to -2dbm. Anyway, when using Rpi as a gateway I can see (from node perspective) very low (-90) TX RSSI, whereas the same parameter is -26 when using arduino serial gateway (with the same close distance between node and the gateway).

Since the TX RSSI is very low, then the ATC works only when you set your target to lower than that, like mine -100 setting for test purposes.

TSD

@prelektr Because I wasn't making much progress, I gave up on this and added an Arduino Nano gateway that communicates with the RPi via UART. Then the ATC works. The Nano (clone) is just a $2 board, so it isn't a big deal to add it.

kted

Any news from the developers on this issue?

RFM69 ATC not working?

12

11.7k

11.2k

113.0k