Bootloading a barebones arduino

Larson

This post is deleted!

Larson

This thread was opened to continue explore how to bootload a project that was giving me fits. The project is based on wonderful work of this thread by NeverDie. That thread explores the testing of many different radios all ridding piggy-back, one at time, on a custom barebones Arduino board using the Atmega328P chip. After building said barebones board, I am having difficulty getting the bootloader loaded on to the board. AlphaHotel has very generously offered some help in a private chat session. At this moment we have been trying to find the right driver for my 7-year-old USBasp V2.0 LC Technology programmer. Bootloaders are typically, I think, installed onto new 328 chips using the SPI interface that the USBasp, as opposed to using USBTTL converters using USART interface.

There is some back story to the help session I’ve already received from AlphaHotel. I’m not going to discuss that history except to say that we tried to install a USB driver using zadig-2.7.exe. The driver we focused on was libusb-win32 driver. I think the challenge here is to get older hardware, such as the USBasp (x32), to work on newer (x64) machines like my newish Windows 10. Our efforts on loading the libusb-win32 driver did not work.
Our newer effort focused on using libusbK as a driver. I found more success with that but no success yet on the barebones bootloader install. So from here, I’ll expose our help session in the form of a thread so that we can communicate and use PIC attachments while documenting the process for others.

Using the libusbK I was able to get some success bootloading. The general idea was to update the USBasp driver, then to test the new driver by bootloading then programming a Nano. If that works, then try to do the same on the barebones board. Two SW methods of bootloadings were used: 1. By using the Arduino IDE environment (Burn Bootloader) and 2. The Windows CMD (Command) application. Here is a summary of my progress with pictures of screens that display the progress.

Zadig driver installation of libusbK. Success!
After unplugging and replugging the USBasp from the computers USB port - Device manager result:
Arduino IDE Test of loading Blink to a Nano using “Upload Using Programmer” using USBasp. Success!
Command prompt and response with Nano Still attached:
Command: avrdude -p m328p -c usbasp
Response:
Reading | ################################################## | 100% 0.03s
avrdude: Device signature = 0x1e950f (probably lgt8fx328p)
avrdude: safemode: Fuses OK (E:FD, H:DA, L:FF)
avrdude done. Thank you.
Success!
Further Arduino IDE Test of USBasp to “Burn Bootloader” to Nano
Success!
Fuse Settings, as shown above (E:FD, H:DA, L:FF)
Success!
Extended test: Try to Burn Bootloader to NeverDie’s barebones board (328) using Arduino IDE. Fail.
Extended test: Try to burn bootloader to NeverDie’s barebonds board (328) using Avrdude. Fail.

Given these last two failures on multiple tries, I’m thinking that I may have toasted the Atmega328p in the process of my soldering and bridge unsoldering. This was my first attempt for such a tiny SMD Atmega328p. I am very sure that I got the right orientation. Or, it could be that the Atmega328p that I purchased came from the bottom of somebody’s barrel.

I continue to work on this and will post results here.

Larson

This post is deleted!

NeverDie

For a "known good" starting point, you could pop the DIP atmega328p out of an arduino uno and practice burning your bootloader into that on a breadboard. If it gives you the same guff, then you know it's your procedure and not the chip that's at fault. Anyhow, as there's not really much that can go wrong, my WAG is that, based on @alphaHotel 's earlier comments requesting a reset-pin breakout (now baked into Version 3.0), it might have something to do with either the means or the assumptions under which your burner is accessing the reset pin.

Myself, I burn the bootloader and fuses in one of those spring-steel clamshell chip holders:
alt text
before soldering it onto the board, so I can't say that I've already done what you are attempting to do. IIRC, they cost only something like $10, but I do understand that simply knowing that doesn't really help you in the moment if you don't have one on hand already and you simply want to push forward with what you've got.

NeverDie

Confirmed. Looking at the schematic of an Arduino Uno R3 and its ICSP:
alt text
you need a direct connection to the reset pin on the chip. For that reason, you can't use the DTR pin to program it, because there's a capacitor in the way. So, that also confirms that Version 3.0 may be a worthwhile upgrade for people like you, thanks to @alphaHotel 's suggestion.

OldSurferDude

@Larson
I'm impressed about how much you have done here. I have a suggestion though I will readily admit to being ignorant about a lot of things.

I have programed Arduino Nano's using the Arduino IDE ISP function. I had some with an old boot loader and some I just needed a touch more space. The programmed Arduino's are functioning as expected, so I don't think there's a problem.

I used this Arduino page and this youtube video to guide me how to program the Nanos. These tell you that you use another Arduino to function as the ISP and how to fashion a cable. (Judging from the discussion here, I'm sure this is not a problem for you.)

My question is, would this work to program a raw Atmega328p chip?

OSD

alphaHotel

Well done, forging ahead, @Larson. I wouldn't jump straight to trying to program a bootloader just yet though, we need to finish confirming communication with the chip and then if/when we get that going, look at how the fuses are set.

Looking at your post here, I believe you got these 328p's from Aliexpress (or similar). Did the listing indicate whether there was a bootloader or not? Bare chips, should be factory set to operate on the internal 8MHz oscillator, so that shouldn't be the problem. How many did you buy?

Based on your results above, at this point, it would seem that one of the following conditions exists:

There are solder bridges (shorts) somewhere - need to test with a MM in continuity mode, each pin with all other pins. Some should be connected (GNDs for example), but most should not.
The connections from your USBasp to the chip are incorrect. Again, you should be able to check this with a multimeter in continuity mode.
The chip is dead. (Long live the chip.)
The fuses are set to require an external crystal that doesn't exist. I just tested this by setting the fuses on my minimal 328P setup (see picture below). The result of which is that I now get the same error that you are getting. This is not likely the case for you but it is a possibility.

Here's a pic I just did checking continuity between the MISO contact on the USBasp and the corresponding chip pin on a minimal setup 328P for reference. Disregard that my multimeter is indicating no continuity, (my son took the picture at a bad time as I was making/breaking contact), you'll get the point of the shot though.

Also, take a close-up picture of the board/chip and post it here for us to see what you've got going on.

Carry on.

AH

EDIT: to add the 4th possible condition.

NeverDie

@Larson I just had an idea that might help you. If you have the Version 1.0 board, then before installing the capacitor on DTR, do a solder bridge across it instead. By doing that the DTR in will be directly connected to the reset pin on your chip, and you can use the DTR pin to gain access to the reset pin on the atmega328p. When you're all done with programming the chip and then later want to switch to using an FTDI to upload your scripts, then at that point you melt the solder bridge and install the capacitor.

Actually, the same would hold true on an Arduino Pro Mini, so if you wanted yet another possible way to practice on a "known good" platform, you could desolder the DTR capacitor, do a solder bridge, and you'd be all set to practice programming the atmega328p chip on it by using the DTR pin on the Arduino Pro Mini as the reset pin during your programming exercise. i.e. you'd solder bridge across capacitor C2 in this Arduino Pro Mini schematic:

https://cdn.sparkfun.com/datasheets/Dev/Arduino/Boards/Arduino-Pro-Mini-v14.pdf

Larson

@NeverDie said in Bootloading a barebones arduino:

Myself, I burn the bootloader and fuses in one of those spring-steel clamshell chip holders:

@NeverDie I just ordered one! Thanks. I didn't know these existed. Slick.

Larson

@NeverDie said in Bootloading a barebones arduino:

For a "known good" starting point, you could pop the DIP atmega328p out of an arduino uno and practice burning your bootloader into that on a breadboard. If it gives you the same guff, then you know it's your procedure and not the chip that's at fault. Anyhow, as there's not really much that can go wrong, my WAG is that, based on @alphaHotel 's earlier comments requesting a reset-pin breakout (now baked into Version 3.0), it might have something to do with either the means or the assumptions under which your burner is accessing the reset pin.

I've got some DIP 328's. Good Idea. I'll try that. Your V1 board has access to Reset. I used an alligator pin to clamp on to the mcu side of the reset switch. So far, I have connected that to the RST pin of the USBasp.

Larson

@OldSurferDude said in Bootloading a barebones arduino:

I have programed Arduino Nano's using the Arduino IDE ISP function. I had some with an old boot loader and some I just needed a touch more space. The programmed Arduino's are functioning as expected, so I don't think there's a problem.

I think I've read that Uploading Using Programmer will install your program, but NOT the bootloader so you end up with a little more room... but no bootloader for the next USART attempted reprogramming.

@OldSurferDude said in Bootloading a barebones arduino:

My question is, would this work to program a raw Atmega328p chip?

Yes, I think that is the aim: turn one 328 into an ISP programmer so that it can 'burn' another 328 via the ICSP connectors. And by 'burn' I mean either the bootloader program, or any other program of your choosing.

Larson

@alphaHotel said in Bootloading a barebones arduino:

I believe you got these 328p's from Aliexpress (or similar). Did the listing indicate whether there was a bootloader or not? Bare chips, should be factory set to operate on the internal 8MHz oscillator, so that shouldn't be the problem. How many did you buy?

Thanks for your post. I bought 5 of these 328s's from https://www.aliexpress.com/item/3256802836313338.html?spm=a2g0o.order_detail.0.0.3f26f19cw3rLj0. Just reviewed the page and there is no mention of bootloader. I presume these are not bootloaded, but that wouldn't stop me from trying a good-old-fashioned Blink program via the USART port.

I checked for continuity bridges on adjacent pins. I'll do that again for regional pins. Earlier I found that detected bridges were visually evident. I now look closely, then test. I can't check USBasp connections enough - I'll do that again. Dead chip? Well, it could be thermally abused given my caveman skill. Fuse settings? Manufactures probably have to make assumptions on this and the prevailing one would probably be for a 16 Mhz crystal.

Sure, I'll take a picture and post. It is a rat's nest at the moment so I'm first going to solder on headers to make things clearer/cleaner to see.

Thanks again for the abundant help!

Larson

@NeverDie said in Bootloading a barebones arduino:

I just had an idea that might help you.

Thanks for the thoughts. I have pretty direct access to the 328p's reset pin now by alligatoring on to the 328p's side of the reset switch. But... If I needed to connect DTR to Reset I think I would leave the capacitor in place and jumper from Reset to DTR. Soldering those capacitors into place is something I really don't want to relive.

@NeverDie said in Bootloading a barebones arduino:

Actually, the same would hold true on an Arduino Pro Mini,

For a known good platform, I've been using the Nano because it has the ICSP direct access to reset. But I see where you were going with the ProMini. Looking at the schematic you attached, I see that direct access to reset exists on JP7, pin 10. That would do it, wouldn't it?

NeverDie

@Larson said in Bootloading a barebones arduino:

Looking at the schematic you attached, I see that direct access to reset exists on JP7, pin 10. That would do it, wouldn't it?

You're right! I forgot about that pin. So on a pro-mini you would have easy-peasy access to the reset pin from the get-go. For that matter same thing on the Arduino Uno R3. You wouldn't need to pop out the DIP chip. You could practice programming it in-situ if you wanted to.

Larson

@alphaHotel said in Bootloading a barebones arduino:

Also, take a close-up picture of the board/chip and post it here for us to see what you've got going on.

Pictures are below. I should add that the ICSP 2x3 cable coloring is:
Black - GND
White - MOSI
Red - VCC
Brown - MISO
Yellow - SCK
Orange - RESET alligatored to bottom of switch.

alphaHotel

@Larson said in Bootloading a barebones arduino:

Manufactures probably have to make assumptions on this and the prevailing one would probably be for a 16 Mhz crystal.

If it's straight from the factory, the fuses will be set to use the internal oscillator and there will be no bootloader.

Looking at your pictures, the chip is well aligned and in the correct orientation. If you're confident in your connections and the USBasp is working well with the Nano but not this chip, then I suspect that the chip was destroyed while being soldered. The fuses-set-for-external-clock possibility is very unlikely and probably not worth the effort to try to test/debug/rectify.

[Side note @NeverDie: I see that you used D20 and D21 to control the LEDs on board. You might want to make a note on the OpenHardware.io page that users will need to utilize either direct Port B manipulation or MCUDude's MiniCore to control those and no crystal can be added to this board (unless you hack the LED and resistor pads to do it).]

@Larson, as you have a few more of those chips, I'd suggest putting this one aside for now and trying again (I'm assuming you have at least 2 other copies of V001 boards as OSHpark tends to sell them in 3-packs). If you want to hold off for a bit to wait for that cool clamshell thing, you might also want to consider ordering the V003 boards while you wait so as to avoid the problem with the traces under the battery holders.

AH

Larson

@alphaHotel said in Bootloading a barebones arduino:

I'd suggest putting this one aside for now and trying again (I'm assuming you have at least 2 other copies of V001 boards as OSHpark tends to sell them in 3-packs).

Thanks again. I will put this aside for a while... eldercare calls anyway. I'm going to order V3 boards and maybe have them fabricated too. The last picture is of the second OSHPark board and second 328p. So I'm down to three 328p's.

I am indebted to this community and I thank everyone for the gracious help.

OldSurferDude

@Larson, you got me thinking and I reviewed the Arduino page on boot loading. It is pretty clear that the Arduino IDE can either load a program or a bootloader. The bootloader code that will reside on the target is part of the Arduino IDE. One only needs to select the Arduino type.

On another note, I was thinking about trying this myself. I went to the link from which you ordered your ATmeg328P and found that the delivered cost (to the USA) was about the same as the delivered price for an Arduino Nano knockoff with bootloader already programmed. I add this information because there are those among us that do not have the skill and experience to do what you are doing.

Personally, I think what you're doing is pretty awesome and I wish you success.

OSD

Larson

@OldSurferDude said in Bootloading a barebones arduino:

...you got me thinking...

This forum is built for that.

Thank you for posting and the link to Arduino Bootloaders. I read that again. In summary of my reading, and in my own words: Bootloaders are the gravel under pavement. So I pose this as a question: If one uses "Sketch/Upload Using Programmer" it will load the program without the bootloader, right? Is that your understanding? Kind of like all pavement, no gravel.

Over several of these exercises bootloading and programming with ICSP's using the Arduino IDE I've noticed that once a program is loaded with the ICSP using "Sketch/Upload Using Programmer", no further USB-TTL (USART) programming can occur until "Tools/Burn Bootloader" is subsequently executed. So in my limited experience, the bootloader is the gateway to normal USART programming. Too many words... I know. But the nice thing about the link you provide is that the Bootloader program is only 512 bytes. So one shouldn't fret over economizing over space.

@OldSurferDude said in Bootloading a barebones arduino:

...skill and experience...

I assume the skill that is required to remove the bootloaded 328P's from the Nano is a higher challenge. Soldering a new chip, as I did, has to be easy-peasy compared to removing and resoldering an existing chip. As it was, I think I killed my new chips because of the soldering & bridge removal. More on that to come in my next post.

@OldSurferDude said in Bootloading a barebones arduino:

...pretty awesome and I wish you success

Kind of you. At this point, I'm kind of a dog with a bone. Given the contributions of NeverDie, AlphaHotel and others, I just have to press on or all the time & effort is for not. Perhaps the dialog is of use to others.

Larson

@alphaHotel said in Bootloading a barebones arduino:

Here's a pic I just did checking continuity between the MISO contact on the USBasp and the corresponding chip pin on a minimal setup 328P for reference.

Motivated by your picture, today I breadboarded a 28 pin DIP 328 and bootloaded, programmed, and even set fuses successfully. That I could do that with my DIP, I think it is proven that I melted my barebones mounted 32 pin SMD. The fun part was using the default fuses and a 16 MHz crystal to make the LED blink (A5, pin 28). When removing the crystal, the blinking stopped. Perfect, it didn't work as expected. Fuses need to be reset. Using what you and @NeverDie taught me I could do this:
First, I discovered the default settings using CMD window and the command: "avrdude -c USBasp -p m328p”
That gives (E:FD, H:DA, L:FF).
Second, I reset the existing fuses (seeking confirmation) with the command: "avrdude -c USBasp -p m328p -U lfuse:w:0xff:m -U hfuse:w:0xda:m -U efuse:w:0xfd:m"
Third, I reset the fuses with "avrdude -c USBasp -p m328p -U lfuse:w:0xc2:m -U hfuse:w:0xdc:m -U efuse:w:0xff:m" based on the Gammon site @NeverDie sent me to.
Then I pulled the crystal... and a thing of beauty ... it worked: led blinking, as expected.

This is proof, to me, that the barebones solder job I did cooked the chip.

I leave this post if it is of use to others, and in gratitude.

Bootloading a barebones arduino

20

11.7k

11.2k

113.1k