OH3, RPi3, GPIO-NRF24 gateway. MySensors binding (ETH or MQTT?)
-
Im a newbie with mySensors. Got interested a few years ago but never got to spend the time to get it up and running. My current system basically consists of RasberryPi3, OH3 and 433Mhz-Nexa-modules (Rfxcom/usb-gateway) that works without any problem.
Now I would like to integrate a relay-board (to control my house ventilation - FTX) into the system as well as some different temp/humidity-sensors and was thinking to do that through MySensors.
System consists of RPI3 + Openhab 3.1.0,
The gateway is the GPIO-mounted module based on NRF24L01+ (https://www.mysensors.org/hardware/rpi-gw-nrf)
Followed the steps presented here to get it up running https://www.mysensors.org/build/raspberry
The OH-mySensors-binding is the one provided by @vores8 in separate thread (https://forum.mysensors.org/topic/11482/oh3-mysensors-binding/114)With a lot of effort and forum-reading I believe the system is fully up and running although Im not 100% sure as I have no sensors yet (thats next step for me).
My questions
My first impression was that the OH-Mysensors-binding no longer was supported and therefore went with the MQTT-based GW. Now I see the binding is working (although not officially supported) and so ETH should still be an option. Should I go for MQTT or ETH based gateway solution and whats the pros and cons?Next question. I understand that solutions based on NRF24 is somewhat outdated and a solution with RFM69 is preferred. Should I stop right here and switch for a system based on RFM69 instead?
As i have no sensors in the system yet, is there an easy way to test the system? Thinking a PC-based MQTT-client that supports mySensors-format? (i already found the MQTT-explorer that I think will be helpful).
Thanks
Per -
Im a newbie with mySensors. Got interested a few years ago but never got to spend the time to get it up and running. My current system basically consists of RasberryPi3, OH3 and 433Mhz-Nexa-modules (Rfxcom/usb-gateway) that works without any problem.
Now I would like to integrate a relay-board (to control my house ventilation - FTX) into the system as well as some different temp/humidity-sensors and was thinking to do that through MySensors.
System consists of RPI3 + Openhab 3.1.0,
The gateway is the GPIO-mounted module based on NRF24L01+ (https://www.mysensors.org/hardware/rpi-gw-nrf)
Followed the steps presented here to get it up running https://www.mysensors.org/build/raspberry
The OH-mySensors-binding is the one provided by @vores8 in separate thread (https://forum.mysensors.org/topic/11482/oh3-mysensors-binding/114)With a lot of effort and forum-reading I believe the system is fully up and running although Im not 100% sure as I have no sensors yet (thats next step for me).
My questions
My first impression was that the OH-Mysensors-binding no longer was supported and therefore went with the MQTT-based GW. Now I see the binding is working (although not officially supported) and so ETH should still be an option. Should I go for MQTT or ETH based gateway solution and whats the pros and cons?Next question. I understand that solutions based on NRF24 is somewhat outdated and a solution with RFM69 is preferred. Should I stop right here and switch for a system based on RFM69 instead?
As i have no sensors in the system yet, is there an easy way to test the system? Thinking a PC-based MQTT-client that supports mySensors-format? (i already found the MQTT-explorer that I think will be helpful).
Thanks
PerReplying myself after more reading and testing.
*MQTT vs ETH probably is equivalent in my system, if the choice if given I think MQTT is preferred.
*NRF24 or RFM69, maybe both as I already have a bunch of NRF24 radios home and can start build directly.
*PC based MQTT could be an idea, but probably its as easy to work through an Arduino-example using the serial monitor in an Arduino-environment.My way forward will be:
Remove the RPi-GPIO-gateway (I built a basic node and tested it, but could not communicate with the GW) and replace it with ESP8266-based WIFI/MQTT/Radio-gateway (one with NRF24 and eventually one with RFM69).I believe that will be an easier way into mySensors-world also limiting the amount of required Linux-related knowledge. It will be easier to debug the system from Arduino IDE-serial console. Ie start and confirm OH3 to MySensors-MQTT-gateway, then proceeding with sensor to gateway communication etc.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login