OTA flash types for MySensors
-
Hi I just wonder if this Spansion, S25FL208K0RMFI040 could be used?
-
About the AT25F512N wich was proposed by @AWI: tbowmo was right, I got confused by Sector, Page and Block erase. Like tbowmo said atmel does call blocks sectors... The AT25F512 does not support Block Erase 64k, which is defined but AFAIK not used in SPIFlash.cpp BUT it is used in the Bootloader if the "Imagesize" is > 32k. But I dont know how Image size is retrieved. Also I think for an ATMega 328p the image size should never be >32k. So this Flashtype could probably work as long as the image size is below 32k. I'd expect the Bootloader to crash or fail when program size is >32k.
About the S25FL... @bjacobse proposed I see the problem that it does not support the Bock Erase 32k opcode which is used in SPIFlash.cpp and Bootloader. Both must be changed when S25FL... should be used. (I would emulate the 32k Block erase by 8 times 4k Block erase.) However remember that Dualoptiboot must also be altered which requires "non-arduino" programming and some work / knowlegde about makefiles / compiler/linker settings in IDE.
-
About the AT25F512N wich was proposed by @AWI: tbowmo was right, I got confused by Sector, Page and Block erase. Like tbowmo said atmel does call blocks sectors... The AT25F512 does not support Block Erase 64k, which is defined but AFAIK not used in SPIFlash.cpp BUT it is used in the Bootloader if the "Imagesize" is > 32k. But I dont know how Image size is retrieved. Also I think for an ATMega 328p the image size should never be >32k. So this Flashtype could probably work as long as the image size is below 32k. I'd expect the Bootloader to crash or fail when program size is >32k.
About the S25FL... @bjacobse proposed I see the problem that it does not support the Bock Erase 32k opcode which is used in SPIFlash.cpp and Bootloader. Both must be changed when S25FL... should be used. (I would emulate the 32k Block erase by 8 times 4k Block erase.) However remember that Dualoptiboot must also be altered which requires "non-arduino" programming and some work / knowlegde about makefiles / compiler/linker settings in IDE.
-
Hey, guys I am currently looking for a (cheap) solution for OTA available in germany. I wanted to use the AT25DF512C-SSHN-B but the only source I could find was aliexpress which only sells 150 pcs at a time (a little too much, although future proof for me I guess ;) ).
I did not really understand this thread so far: is there another model that works with my sensors?Or do you by chance know a place where I can get some of the AT25DF512C-SSHN-B ones here in europe? Thanks!
-
Hey, guys I am currently looking for a (cheap) solution for OTA available in germany. I wanted to use the AT25DF512C-SSHN-B but the only source I could find was aliexpress which only sells 150 pcs at a time (a little too much, although future proof for me I guess ;) ).
I did not really understand this thread so far: is there another model that works with my sensors?Or do you by chance know a place where I can get some of the AT25DF512C-SSHN-B ones here in europe? Thanks!
@LastSamurai said:
AT25DF512C
Well not in EU, but you can order from DigiKey or Mouser if everything else fails - thats where I order my parts.
EDIT: And I live in DK - maybe worth mentioning.
BR Jonas
-
@LastSamurai said:
AT25DF512C
Well not in EU, but you can order from DigiKey or Mouser if everything else fails - thats where I order my parts.
EDIT: And I live in DK - maybe worth mentioning.
BR Jonas
@LastSamurai said:
AT25DF512C-SSHN-B
Thanks, but both have shipping costs of abount 20€ (if you pay <50€ overall). Or is there a way around it?
I also found SST25VF020B‑80‑4I‑SAE and 25VF512A33-4C-SA flash modules in german stores though. Would they work too?
-
@LastSamurai said:
AT25DF512C-SSHN-B
Thanks, but both have shipping costs of abount 20€ (if you pay <50€ overall). Or is there a way around it?
I also found SST25VF020B‑80‑4I‑SAE and 25VF512A33-4C-SA flash modules in german stores though. Would they work too?
@LastSamurai Yes, thats true. My order is always above the "free shipping" limit :-)
I'll give the datasheets a look, of the devices you mentioned.BR Jonas
-
@LastSamurai The SST25VF020B... should work fine with the 2.0 developversion and #define MY_SPIFLASH_SST25TYPE set. It seems to be very close to the SST25PF020B I used. However keep an eye on the even more limited voltage range of the SST25VF Type which needs at least 2,7V which would be a problem if you want to power your circuit directly by 2xNiMH Batteries.
The SST25VF512 needs also 2,7V but additionally does not support the 64k erase command (see my comments on that issue some posts above where I wrote something about the AT25F512).
-
I have AT25512N-SH-T SOIC-8 -> http://www.mouser.com/ds/2/36/Atmel-5165-SEEPROM-AT25512-Datasheet-476711.pdf
Anyone knows if it is fully interchangeable with AT25DF512C? I cannot see any difference from the datasheet. The pinout is the same.
-
Hello,
Would AT45DB041E be a good choice as a OTA flash? I see it's in the schematics for the new Sensebender Micro mk2.
https://www.adestotech.com/wp-content/uploads/doc8783.pdf
BR
Martin -
Hello,
Would AT45DB041E be a good choice as a OTA flash? I see it's in the schematics for the new Sensebender Micro mk2.
https://www.adestotech.com/wp-content/uploads/doc8783.pdf
BR
Martin -
Hi all,
A question, why don't use an EPPROM SPI 25AA020A or 25AA512?
They works between 1.8 and 5.5V.
BR
Xavier@XavTroniC said in OTA flash types for MySensors:
25AA512
Seems these are only 2K in size.
I would like something similar though! -
@XavTroniC said in OTA flash types for MySensors:
25AA512
Seems these are only 2K in size.
I would like something similar though! -
Hello,
Would AT45DB041E be a good choice as a OTA flash? I see it's in the schematics for the new Sensebender Micro mk2.
https://www.adestotech.com/wp-content/uploads/doc8783.pdf
BR
Martin@mardah said in OTA flash types for MySensors:
Would AT45DB041E be a good choice as a OTA flash? I see it's in the schematics for the new Sensebender Micro mk2.
Did you ever figure out if this works with Optiboot for OTA flashing?
I must admit that i'm very confused at this thread, it was setup to advise of other Flash IC's for us to use but there seems to be no 'solid' alternatives that you guys have suggested. For me, living in the UK, its near impossible to grab any of the AT25DF512C-SSHN-B without paying through the roof for shipping.
I can see that AT45DB041E is JEDEC compliant but that is as far as i can go with knowing if it will work. Flash architecture is way out of my depth right now.
MySensors 2.1.1
Controller - OpenHAB (Virtual Machine)
Gateway - Arduino Mega MQTT Gateway W5100 -
@mardah said in OTA flash types for MySensors:
Would AT45DB041E be a good choice as a OTA flash? I see it's in the schematics for the new Sensebender Micro mk2.
Did you ever figure out if this works with Optiboot for OTA flashing?
I must admit that i'm very confused at this thread, it was setup to advise of other Flash IC's for us to use but there seems to be no 'solid' alternatives that you guys have suggested. For me, living in the UK, its near impossible to grab any of the AT25DF512C-SSHN-B without paying through the roof for shipping.
I can see that AT45DB041E is JEDEC compliant but that is as far as i can go with knowing if it will work. Flash architecture is way out of my depth right now.
@Samuel235 said in OTA flash types for MySensors:
AT45DB041E
Hello. This chip (AT45DB041E) has no erase 32kb command (0x52), status read command has a strange opcode too (D7h). So it is no trivial task to use this chip.
I can suggest Micron M25P40 as widespread IC. But it requires one trick and I will try to describe it. This chip has no erase 32kb command (0x52) too. It means OTA code will not erase memory and update will be failed. We (me and Yury) bumped into this problem when we started intensive tests of my nodes before production (we use micron M25P40). Moreover, when I try to investigate inexpensive avaliable chips I find an interesting thing. Chips with 64kb erase option (0xD8 opcode) are more common than chips with 32kb erase option (which support 64kb erase option too). So it can be worth adapting mysensors for use of any flash chip which supports 64kb erase option. To adapt your sketches you should do only two things- Add this code into your sketch after including mysensors.h
#define SPIFLASH_BLOCKERASE_32K 0xD8So OTA library will call erase 64kb command instead of erase 32kb command. It is very easy.
2) You should use Bootloader which calls erase 64kb command instead of 32kb command.
Bad news. It is not an easy task and you should recompile dual optiboot and burn it. :anguished:
Good news. I've recompliled dual optiboot and all my nodes will burn with it by default. :yum:My changes in bootloader are very simple but it sutable for my boards. We update it many many times and the process is absolutely bulletproof (especially after Tekka's update :+1: ).
But how about a more universal solution? I think it is not too hard to modify dual optiboot to check flash first 10 bytes (OTA flag) after 32kb erase command call and try another command? I will try this idea later but may be someone will do it faster :smiley: -
@Samuel235 said in OTA flash types for MySensors:
AT45DB041E
Hello. This chip (AT45DB041E) has no erase 32kb command (0x52), status read command has a strange opcode too (D7h). So it is no trivial task to use this chip.
I can suggest Micron M25P40 as widespread IC. But it requires one trick and I will try to describe it. This chip has no erase 32kb command (0x52) too. It means OTA code will not erase memory and update will be failed. We (me and Yury) bumped into this problem when we started intensive tests of my nodes before production (we use micron M25P40). Moreover, when I try to investigate inexpensive avaliable chips I find an interesting thing. Chips with 64kb erase option (0xD8 opcode) are more common than chips with 32kb erase option (which support 64kb erase option too). So it can be worth adapting mysensors for use of any flash chip which supports 64kb erase option. To adapt your sketches you should do only two things- Add this code into your sketch after including mysensors.h
#define SPIFLASH_BLOCKERASE_32K 0xD8So OTA library will call erase 64kb command instead of erase 32kb command. It is very easy.
2) You should use Bootloader which calls erase 64kb command instead of 32kb command.
Bad news. It is not an easy task and you should recompile dual optiboot and burn it. :anguished:
Good news. I've recompliled dual optiboot and all my nodes will burn with it by default. :yum:My changes in bootloader are very simple but it sutable for my boards. We update it many many times and the process is absolutely bulletproof (especially after Tekka's update :+1: ).
But how about a more universal solution? I think it is not too hard to modify dual optiboot to check flash first 10 bytes (OTA flag) after 32kb erase command call and try another command? I will try this idea later but may be someone will do it faster :smiley:@Koresh - Thank you for explaining this to me. I think i understand this a little more clearly now. Like i said, i've never dealt with flash so its all a grey area for myself.
I'm currently looking at recompiling MYSBootloader for use with an 8Mhz crystal instead of this work around. The whole reasoning behind me asking this question is simply because i wanted OTA updates on a battery powered node. Now, this means i need OTA updates on 3.3v, but my MYSBootloader nodes require 16Mhz crystal to work. So its either use 16Mhz on 3.3v (while it works, its not the correct solution) OR to get a bootloader working with an 8Mhz crystal setup. I chose the later, and therefor its either recompile MYSBootloader to work with 8Mhz OR to get a flash IC on the board to allow for Dual Optiboot.
At the moment i'm toying with the idea of going the software issue route and attempting to recompile MYSBootloader for 8Mhz (just need to workout what to change for the recompiled version). Seems a little easier and cheaper than going the route of flash considering my location and not being able to get my hands on the recommended/mostly used flash IC.
-
@Samuel235 said in OTA flash types for MySensors:
AT45DB041E
Hello. This chip (AT45DB041E) has no erase 32kb command (0x52), status read command has a strange opcode too (D7h). So it is no trivial task to use this chip.
I can suggest Micron M25P40 as widespread IC. But it requires one trick and I will try to describe it. This chip has no erase 32kb command (0x52) too. It means OTA code will not erase memory and update will be failed. We (me and Yury) bumped into this problem when we started intensive tests of my nodes before production (we use micron M25P40). Moreover, when I try to investigate inexpensive avaliable chips I find an interesting thing. Chips with 64kb erase option (0xD8 opcode) are more common than chips with 32kb erase option (which support 64kb erase option too). So it can be worth adapting mysensors for use of any flash chip which supports 64kb erase option. To adapt your sketches you should do only two things- Add this code into your sketch after including mysensors.h
#define SPIFLASH_BLOCKERASE_32K 0xD8So OTA library will call erase 64kb command instead of erase 32kb command. It is very easy.
2) You should use Bootloader which calls erase 64kb command instead of 32kb command.
Bad news. It is not an easy task and you should recompile dual optiboot and burn it. :anguished:
Good news. I've recompliled dual optiboot and all my nodes will burn with it by default. :yum:My changes in bootloader are very simple but it sutable for my boards. We update it many many times and the process is absolutely bulletproof (especially after Tekka's update :+1: ).
But how about a more universal solution? I think it is not too hard to modify dual optiboot to check flash first 10 bytes (OTA flag) after 32kb erase command call and try another command? I will try this idea later but may be someone will do it faster :smiley:
