[SOLVED] 2 X nrf24l01+pa+lna with RF24_PA_MAX

[Oitzu]

External 2xAA batteries for my tests. In the final use case I will add a 3.3V voltage regulator. I got a tip yesterday that this could be a matter of inproper shielding to the module itself. Sounds like a plausible explanation to me. I will try today to shield the module from his own rf with tin foil.

[Oitzu]

Just if anybody else is running into this problem:
Shielding the module with tinfoil against RF worked great! With the tinfoil shield i got over 1km reach in a clear line of sight!

[Zeph]

Wow. A little better!

I assume that's at 250 Kbps? Did you do any range tests at different speeds?

The nRF24L01+ with LNA & PA & antenna is not that much more expensive than the rfm69* so for some applications that need the higher speed they are still in the running even with longer distances.

I saw an analsyis (maybe here?) which suggested that this setup would not do very much good for reception, which was more limited by the noise floor, such that the antenna gain and LNA would not improve things much - so most of the range gain would come from the increased transmit power (including antenna gain). This was a theoretic analysis, not an empircal test.

If true, it would mean that using an enhanced power unit on one end of the link only would not give one much additional range in bidirectional protocols, where the back-link (conventional to enhanced) would be the limiting factor. I've been curious if this is indeed the case or not in practice.

[Fabien]

@Oitzu do you have some photo of your module with shielding ?

[Oitzu]

@Zeph Only tried 250kbps at the moment, i tried to test the maximum range possible.
But i will also do some 1mbit and 2 mbit tests in the near future (depends on weather).

Hm.. i don't know what exactly do the performance gain. I also ordered some modules with external antenna but without external LNA+PA. Let's see what the LNA+PA really do. ;)

@Fabien: I will post a photo tomorrow. But basicly i just wraped cling film arround the module (to not get any shorts) and then wraped tin foil arround that.

[Oitzu]

@Fabien:

Surely doesn't look "professional" but it works. In the final installation i will try to add aluminum tape to the inside of the project box.

[Zeph]

@Oitzu The range was greatly improved by using a far-aday cage.

[Oitzu]

@Zeph: Yeah i understand that. I meant if the pa all alone or if the lna also plays a role with this modules.
Because you mentioned that the lna probably doesn't play a role in this.

[Fabien]

Thank you !

[Zeph]

@Zeph said:

@Oitzu The range was greatly improved by using a far-aday cage.

Sorry, it was meant to be a throw-away pun, not an insight.

[Oitzu]

@Zeph said:

@Zeph said:

@Oitzu The range was greatly improved by using a far-aday cage.

Sorry, it was meant to be a throw-away pun, not an insight.

... now i got it... haha... sorry. You know how many germans does it takes to change a lightbulb?
One. We are very efficient and don't have humour. ;)

[wico2002]

@Oitzu questions: on the picture, the foil cover up the base of the antenna. Can it touch the antenna connector itself (golden part the antenna is screw on) or this part also need to be covered with plastic film ?

You also told you will try to cover up the inside of the case with foil to not wrap the radio itself... did you try it ?

[Oitzu]

@wico2002: you should also cover the base of the antenna with plastic foil.
As far as i know the base is grounded. I don't really know if this makes any difference but i let my tinfoil ungrounded. I'm no expert in RF mechanics. :D

No not tried this yet.. but this should have the same effect as the tinfoil wrapping.
As long as you let stick the antenna out of the housing.... ;)

[wico2002]

@Oitzu A BIG THANK YOU, it work now with the foil trick. I'll will maybe close other forum topics including your topic's url. thank you again

[Dwalt]

Using @Oitzu 's trick, I wrapped my iBoard Gateway in aluminum tape. I can't tell if there is any benefit in transmission range or reduced interference but at least it looks nice and shiny!

[Oitzu]

@Dwalt will this box also sends packets to the path of valallah?

[Dwalt]

@Oitzu Yes, now my network will ride eternal!

Actually, my brother saw the modification and asked if I was trying to prevent the NSA from intercepting my humidity readings. Hmmm, maybe a secondary benefit...

[doblanch]

Finally does the foil should be grounded or not ??
thanks

[mfalkvidd]

Grounding the foil will not affect the shininess, but it could improve the shielding.

[doblanch]

@mfalkvidd thanks for your reply.
If we want to ground it, can we use the gold base ? I guess that this part is grounded....

I met some issues with PA LNA, do you think that it can freeze after a while, and powering the NRF24+PA+LNA directly on the nano ? It seems that after one month of use, I loss many packets..