💬 Battery Powered Sensors

[tssk]

I hope I am measuring it correctly.

It shows 12.5 when in sleep and up to 90 when transmitting/measuring.

Any one can interpret that for me please? :)

[skywatch]

@tssk That is 12.5mA (12500uA) in sleep and up to 90mA (90000uA) in transmit mode. Compare that to my door/window sensor which is <5uA sleep and about 15uA transmit with nrf24l01+). Your current draw is too high for most 'normal' batteries to last very long as you have found out.

Minicore info and install instructions is here -- https://github.com/MCUdude/MiniCore.

Pull-up resistors are on the pcb and connect between data and Vcc as well as clock to Vcc. You won't gain a lot tampering with those with the figures you have posted so I would forget about those at the moment and concentrate on more productive things to get a lower current.

here is the bit of code to only send sensor variable when it has changed.....

if (int != oldint) {
    send(msgInt.set(int));
    oldint = int;
  }

This is used in my door sensor and can be used with any sensor variable name.

ALso of help would be to re-flash the node with MY_DEBUG to see how often your node is measuring and sending data. It shows if your prog is working as your expected it to (or not).

Anoother thought is that the sleep interval does not have to be fixed. You can vary it so that some times of day it is 20-30mins between read/send and at others you can reduce it if you think you need to.

[mfalkvidd]

@skywatch said in 💬 Battery Powered Sensors:

@tssk That is 12.5mA (12500uA) in sleep and up to 90mA (90000uA) in transmit mode. Compare that to my door/window sensor which is <5uA sleep and about 15uA transmit with nrf24l01+

You mean 15mA transmit, right?

[tssk]

I removed the step up booster connected + directly to VCC but the node stopped working - only the arduino onboard led is constantly on.

I also tried to measure the step up booster alone and it is showing 0.05 at 20mA on multimeter settings.

I am now really confused and I am not sure what to conclude from that...

[skywatch]

@mfalkvidd Yes - you got me ;)

I was confusing it with the battery pir which is 15-16uA in trigger mode. But yes, 15mA in Tx mode with a nrf24 module.

Maybe it is time for me to hibernate for a few months after all .....

[tssk]

@tssk said in 💬 Battery Powered Sensors:

I removed the step up booster connected + directly to VCC but the node stopped working - only the arduino onboard led is constantly on.

The problem was that the batteries I used were not completely fresh. I googled that Arduino pro mini need at least 2.7V to operate. Using fresh batteries the node is working. And it shows 6.0mA in sleep and 25.4mA when transmitting.

So using the stepup booster adds 6.5mA in sleep and 65mA when transmitting to consumption?

I also found LowPower library (https://github.com/rocketscream/Low-Power) but it seems to interfere with mysensors library (https://github.com/rocketscream/Low-Power/issues/80). Any experience?

[skywatch]

@tssk

The 2.7V is set in the fuses, you can go a lot lower if you disable Bod completely. I tested one with nrf24 and it worked down to 1.64V.

I think you will find that all the 'good stuff' from the low power library is included in mysensors sleep function anyway.

I suggest using minicore (it is easy to install and all works from within the arduino IDE you are used to) and set internal oscillator and disable BoD. You will need a programmer (a few dollars) or you can use another arduino as programmer. but that is more time consuming to set up and easier to mess up as well!

Good that you got rid of the booster!

[tssk]

@skywatch said in 💬 Battery Powered Sensors:

I think you will find that all the 'good stuff' from the low power library is included in mysensors sleep function anyway.

So when I use sleep() mysensors library overloads the generic arduino sleep?

I suggest using minicore (it is easy to install and all works from within the arduino IDE you are used to) and set internal oscillator and disable BoD. You will need a programmer (a few dollars) or you can use another arduino as programmer. but that is more time consuming to set up and easier to mess up as well!

I look at the git repo and I more confused now. I thought it is some kind of bootloader/firmware I flash. What is Arduino core? I never heard that term.

Good that you got rid of the booster!

I wonder why the booster is recommended here https://www.mysensors.org/build/battery ? Or did I misinterpreted?

[mfalkvidd]

@tssk said in 💬 Battery Powered Sensors:

I wonder why the booster is recommended here https://www.mysensors.org/build/battery ? Or did I misinterpreted?

If you interpreted

Note that a booster can be a bit noisy (and disturb the radio). The booster is also less than 100% efficient, so boosting can be less efficient than just powering the Arduino directly from the batteries and change batteries when they hit 2.8V.

as a recommendation, I would say that you did a slight misinterpretation. But it depends on what sensors you use and how much the device will be sleeping.

[evb]

@tssk In following post I have described my adventures in building a battery powered door node : https://forum.mysensors.org/topic/11499/checking-mechanical-locked-doors-by-a-battery-based-windows-door-sensor-node?_=1614421889744
Search for the section : The battery-based windows/door sensor node : software
I explain there the use of the minicore package.
See also the section References at the end for more information about battery powered nodes

[tssk]

So I ordered Arduino Uno for programming my Pro Minis. And going to experiment with 2xAA or 3xAA setup without step up booster (they are whining anyway so I will be happy if I get rid of it :)

Thank everyone for help!

[nekitoss]

I have a problem: when batteries go around 2.7V radio will stop transmitting. Board still take current, but no messages.
I'm using own board with barebone 328p (8mHz internal) and SMD/mini nrf24l01 (pretty shure china)
Did anyone had same issues?

I've checked programmaticaly (yes, it is possible!) my fuse bits: Low=0xE2, High=0xD2, Extended=0xFE (0x06)
(BOD = 1.8V)
I've have three same boards (water leak) and used other not-yet-installed with specially made low-voltage regulated source (with 2200 uF capacitor and resistor load to eliminate voltage drop at transmission) to test - same result.
Sometimes i can go lower to 2.5V but not guaranteed, sometimes even corrupted messages (i.e. node id 168 instead 8).
Tests were without UART, only MYSController to monitor messages flooding each 5sec to approve life.

Did anyone had same problems with nrf24l01 modules? All i see people say the can go to around 2.0 V.

According to article https://www.gammon.com.au/power (and datasheet)
at 8mHz i'm safe down to 2.4V (something like that i also measured)
nrf should go down to 1.9...

Also it would be great to add into advanced section possible voltages and problems with NiMh, china modules & 2.7V(if not only me), [not]possible currents from coin cells and metioned article.

[nekitoss]

@nekitoss said in 💬 Battery Powered Sensors:

It would be great to add to this arctle that if you want to be battery powered outdoors with temperature below zero - you have to use lithium batteries (FR6 for AA) (yes, batteries, not li-ion accumulators!) (for example ultimate lithium energizer, also could be found lithium batteries from other vendors), because Alkaline (LR6 for AA) will be frozen and loose their capacity heavily. If i remember it is >50% at -10 C and death at -20 C. Same problem for li-ion accumulators - when liquid is frozen - electrons are stucked...
Also would be great to add some link about battery/accumulator types, advanteges and disadvantages, but i have no links in english, easy-to-read and in one place...

But i have very great link about battery-powering that really should be added here, but in advanced section:
http://www.gammon.com.au/power

@zboblamont how your alkaline batteries experience after 2 years(temperatures, lasting time)? my freshly installed (yes, it was long develop and test...) Lithium AA - when few weeks ago it was -20 .. stopped transmitting! Fixed resetting power when it become little warmer. Possibly same problem with 2.7V or exactly there may be wrong BOD...

[skywatch]

@nekitoss If I were you I;d reflash the bootloader and chec again. I got my pro mini with ebyte nrf24 to work and register with the gateway all the way down to 1.63V, so somethingi is wrong if you are loosing it at 2.7V (which is also as it happens, a BoD setting for atmel 328p). For the test I used minicore bootloader iwth Bod disabled and 2MHz clock. Bench power supply for the voltage variation.

[zboblamont]

@nekitoss No problems with alkaline power, 6 - 18 months now on 2xAA down to ca -15c, battery voltage reported ca 2 or 3 times per day.
I vaguely recall reading an article on lithium and alkaline battery behaviour in extreme cold weather, the alkalines were the better performers.

Note that the pro-minis here use onboard booster and LDO which provide stable 3.3v all the way down to ca 1.8v battery death, so battery voltage is unrelated to system voltage unlike your setup. They also use rfm69s (433MHz) which are better able to penetrate structural obstacles.
Bear in mind that if you have comms problems this can substantially reduce battery life as it does not quickly waken, perform the task and go back to deep sleep

[skywatch]

@mfalkvidd

Nice job on updating the infor BTW :)

[Puneit Thukral]

Adding on to this.. If we use a map function to convert the battery level like this, then it shows up as an attribute in HomeAssistant and Homekit

Map function works and not the percent. The percent always shows as zero in Homekit.
Hope this helps someone!

void battery()
{
  long batteryMillivolts = hwCPUVoltage();
  int batteryV =batteryMillivolts /1000 + 0.5;
  auto batteryLevel = map(batteryV,EMPTY_BATTERY, FULL_BATTERY, 0, 100);
  if (batteryLevel > 100) 
  {batteryLevel=100;}

#ifdef MY_DEBUG
  Serial.print("Battery voltage: ");
  Serial.print(batteryMillivolts / 1000.0);
  Serial.println("V");
  Serial.print("Battery Level ");
  Serial.print(batteryLevel);
  Serial.println(" %");
#endif

  if (oldBatteryLevel != batteryLevel) {
    sendBatteryLevel(batteryLevel);
    send(msgV.set(batteryV,2));
    oldBatteryLevel = batteryLevel;
  }
}


[nekitoss]

@skywatch Thank you very much! Your advice helped. Not shure what it was on BOTH devices - my mistake or some corruption of fuses/program.
On first device (where i found problem) - there were different fuse bits (but according to my eyes BOD was even disabed, but not shure). On the second (where i tested) fuses were checked and were correct. I tried to play with fuses and erase chip... and something strange happened - or chip memory was broken or i can't verify program when box "erase flash and eeprom" is checked... so i took fresh nano, programmed it and resoldered MCU into the second device.
So both devices now are fixed and tested - both work till ~1.9V.
Thanks, you saved my brains!

[skywatch]

@nekitoss Yay! :)

Well done on getting it working!

[Gilles BILLARD]

Hi from France;
I've tried everything I could and no way to put My temp. sensor to deep sleep.
so I went back to the very beginning with a bare Pro-Min 3.3v and I tryed this:

---

#include <LowPower.h>
void setup() {
pinMode(13, OUTPUT);
}
void loop() {
LowPower.powerDown(SLEEP_8S, ADC_OFF, BOD_OFF);
digitalWrite(13, HIGH);
delay(1000);
digitalWrite(13, LOW);
}

---

My boad is going to sleep;
YEEEESSS ! the pb is NOT comming from the board itself....eating a bunch ou micro amp;
Then I've added the minimum requested to make a MySensor extension and I tried this:

---

#define MY_RADIO_NRF24 // Choix du module radio
#define MY_RF24_PA_LEVEL (RF24_PA_HIGH) //CHOIX: RF24_PA_MIN; RF24_PA_LOW; RF24_PA_HIGH; RF24_PA_MAX
#define RF24_CHANNEL 76
#define RF24_DATARATE RF24_250KBPS
#include <MySensors.h>
#include <LowPower.h>
void setup() {
pinMode(13, OUTPUT);
}
void loop() {
LowPower.powerDown(SLEEP_8S, ADC_OFF, BOD_OFF);
digitalWrite(13, HIGH);
delay(1000);
digitalWrite(13, LOW);
}

---

The boad stays awaken (4 mA current)
So may be the problem is comming from LowPower library...
I tried this minimal prgm recommended in a tutorial, using MySensors library and SLEEP function:

---

// Enable and select radio type attached
#define MY_RADIO_RF24
#include <MySensors.h>
uint32_t SLEEP_TIME = 900000; // sleep time between reads (in seconds * 1000 )
int oldBatteryPcnt = 0;
#define FULL_BATTERY 3 // 3V for 2xAA alkaline. Adjust if you use a different battery setup.
void setup()
{
}
void presentation()
{
// Send the sketch version information to the gateway and Controller
sendSketchInfo("Battery Meter", "1.0");
}
void loop()
{
// get the battery Voltage
long batteryMillivolts = hwCPUVoltage();
int batteryPcnt = batteryMillivolts / FULL_BATTERY / 1000.0 * 100 + 0.5;
if (oldBatteryPcnt != batteryPcnt) {
sendBatteryLevel(batteryPcnt);
oldBatteryPcnt = batteryPcnt;
}
sleep(SLEEP_TIME);
}

---

NO WAY AGAIN; The board is still eating 4mA all the way long.
I'm lost !!!! Please HELP ME ....