Add new V_ACTION behavior for window shade/cover (and perhaps others)


  • Hardware Contributor

    Hi,

    I made a simple scenario for each of my shades/covers /roller blind (name them as you whish ! :))
    They are controller from just ONE button :
    If I push the button :
    When the blind is idle, If the previous move was a UP, I make them go down, else I make them go UP
    If the blind is already moving (I move them for a certain amount of time), stop them.

    So, my feature request is : add a V_ACTION new type.
    Of course, the behavior of the blind has to be handled by the arduino program.

    The S_COVER would so have : V_UP, V_DOWN, V_STOP, V_PERCENTAGE, V_ACTION.

    The same type could also be used for lights : When I press a switch button (doorbell kind), I could send a V_ACTION to a light node (S_DIMMER or S_BINARY) : It would toggle itself depending of his state.

    Edit : I found a Github issue that seems very similar to my request :
    https://github.com/mysensors/MySensors/issues/724

    sbrinkmann created this issue in mysensors/MySensors

    open New set/req type V_TOGGLE #724



  • I find V_ACTION too generic and would rather name it V_TRIGGER or something. Besides that I find the idea quite nice!


  • Hardware Contributor

    Yes , or perhaps V_DEFAULT_ACTION ?


  • Hero Member

    @napo7 I think it would be a confusing type as the action is not clear. If you choose to have one button to control a multiple action device a simple V_STATUS = ON can do the trick.


  • Hardware Contributor

    V_STATUS=ON is even more confusing : I still want to be able to toggle the light from a controller, so I'll have to sens status on and off from controller.



  • Why, just always send V_STATUS=ON and implement it properly in your node (i.e. toggle on reception).


Log in to reply
 

Looks like your connection to MySensors Forum was lost, please wait while we try to reconnect.