💬 MyMultisensors

[scalz]

@NeverDie saying this you're challenging me lol more seriously, I have no real issue.
what would you simplify? can't be more simple imho. no regulator, just batt.. I still can use 2xaa/aaa. That would ease a bit. the circuit works fine as expected but that would be less fun without optimizations

Things I have thought when I did my choice:

• as the pir analog is sensitive, I wanted no regul for this one. or I would go for a booster and then more hardware debug (I have already a one cell optimized design that I plan to try with this pir, just to know if there will be a rev2 lol..). But that would need more care&filtering with good quality components (shielded inductors, ferrites, capacitors...) to prevent false trigger.
  Like this one I did https://forum.mysensors.org/topic/2951/my-mysx-multisensors-board or my ulpnode clone That would be an overall more expensive solution. but with less maintenance and one cell
• use 1uA digital PIR...not cheap
• use a better mcu like cc1310 with its power domains and events. but not mysensors/arduino.
• coincell is just for the fun as this design. and like I said I can use 2 lithium or alkaline.

[scalz]

Few pics of another board i have just assembled. I have just noticed I didn't show any proof/pics

Top view

With this lense, I get 5-6m.

Bottom view, with rfm69, coincell holder and AVRSPI/FTDI connector.

I am waiting for rev 1.1 pcb. No big changes, I improved a bit silkscreen, removed the schmitt trigger to save some power and in place i use pinchange int, makes more sense. Few routes and size changed.
Though, 328p is memory limited, I have to disable debug for this one!

[scalz]

nothing fancy, just wanted to share how this is working as we're all busy..

there is a small problem with my widgets but no matter I show you what this board outputs if you're curious, and I'm beginning to like this board

I will change my dashboard later, it's just for fun.

For power consumption, few reference for sleep time : old VC506 multimeter but working well + uCurrent Gold

• PIR enabled, other sensors+MCU in deep sleep with interrupt on pins : 4-5uA for Varta CR2032 coincell, 3-4uA for 2xAAA Duracell
• PIR enabled, other sensors+MCU in deep sleep with interrupt on pins + WDT enabled : 11uA for the coincell, 8uA for 2xAAA
• PIR enabled, MCU active 1Mhz, other sensors sleeping with interrupt on pins + WDT enabled : 730-740uA for both

not that bad
I have an other proto waiting (for fun because i do not really need it lol). it's another version not for coincell, but as thin and much smaller! with ota back. I thought for coincell, ota or chain tx pulse, was a bit too much battery killer..even if CR2450 imho...and with our preferred lib there are multiple chain tx for presentation, some signing stuff etc..and you can't pause this to limit internal resisitance of the coincell..

The sketch is still in progress. I mean it's working of course, but still looking to improve a bit things..but i can show you the infos and commands which are available for the controller. That should help to save enough power I think:

// For controller. CHILD_ID are presented. CMDID are not presented to not charge radio tx. But are available from controller, using receive()
//  CHILD NODE ID/CMD           ID    Description
#define CHILD_ID_PIR            1     // PIR sensor 
#define CHILD_ID_TEMP           2     // Temperature sensor
#define CHILD_ID_HUM            3     // Humidity sensor
#define CHILD_ID_LIGHT          4     // Ambiant light Child node ID
#define CHILD_ID_BATT_SENSOR    5     // Battery voltage, % is reported by sendbattery stuff
#define CHILD_ID_RSSI           6     // Radio rssi
#define CHILD_ID_DOOR           7     // Door reed switch
#define CHILD_ID_PIR_EN         8     // Enable PIR 
#define CMID_FULL               10    // Command from controller with all params below in one tx. below is more for debug..
#define CMID_PULSES             11    // Command from controller to set PIR number of pulse for windows time 
#define CMID_WINDOWTIME         12    // Command from controller to set PIR window time   
#define CMID_BLINDTIME          13    // Command from controller to set PIR blind time   
#define CMID_CANCELTIME         14    // Command from controller to set PIR cancel time
#define CMID_EN_LIGHT           15    // Command from controller to enable Light sensor threshold 
#define CMID_LIGHT_MODE         16    // Command from controller to set Light sensor special mode (for instance, enable pir at certain light level only...) 
#define CMID_LIGHT_H            17    // Command from controller to set Light sensor high threshold 
#define CMID_LIGHT_L            18    // Command from controller to set Light sensor low threshold 
#define CMID_LIGHT_DELTA        19    // Command from controller to set difference of lux for update controller 
#define CMID_TRANSMIT_INTERVAL  20    // Command from controller to set time between sensor updates
#define CMID_TH_DELTA           21    // Command from controller to set difference of temp/hum for update controller 
#define CMID_EN_LED             22    // Command from controller to set led

See you soon

[carlierd]

Hello,

Very complete board !

How did you report RSSI ? It is RSSI of the node or the gateway ?

David.

[scalz]

@carlierd hello. hehe yep a bit complete, very memory ric-rac limited It's rssi of the node tuned by ATC I have modified libs, but i'm late on pr...sorry

[carlierd]

@scalz I will wait. I am curious to see the result on my nodes !

[scalz]

Yo,

for those who have not seen my latest rev..apologize, I'm working hard to release all my stuff
It's still working well btw. this is the revision i will release i think (i have few other nice iteration but that's enough!).

• Size is 25mmx49mm (same size as a nodemcu)
• Same specs as before, plus OTA. So optimized for very low power and coincell management. Temp/hum/pir/lux/contact door input
• Thickness depends on the battery used. That's great as now it's possible to use different kind of battery holder CR2032 for the thinnest (8mm without PIR) very thin!, CR2450, or through hole 2xAAA holder
• you can see a test I want to try: a special antenna i saw on the forum. I will compare it with straight wire antenna, and coiled wire antenna.

See you soon

[scalz]

another little pic

left to right: 1) pcb without holder, 2) with cr2032 holder, 3) cr2450, 4) 2xaaa
different antenna format, i have not compared yet. But the straight one, if i remember well, reached 40-50m range with one brick wall (All are the low power version of rfm69, CW). As you can see the coiled antenna (4) does not take so much place compared to the 1.9€ special ant (3).
I can cover a nice range of use, yeah

[carlierd]

Very good job !

When will share the schematic ?
How is responding the PIR ?

And off course, how is the battery usage ? So many sensors could discharge it faster ...

David.

[scalz]

Hi @carlierd

i'll fix this! There is still my first version i posted there, on the old topic, https://forum.mysensors.org/topic/3600/my-other-pir-multisensor-on-coin-cell

PIR is repsonding well, depending of the sensitivity i set in sketch. same for batt!
Many sensors but all low power Except reed switch option, of course my power consumption results above are without reed switch. If i need it, i use a 1M res min (increase a few uA).

see you soon

[Anticimex]

This looks good!
@scalz The PIR parts, are they based on the app note I showed you way back?

[scalz]

@anticimex almost! in fact i noticed that's mostly the same schematic if you look at different source. of course it's a PIR ! Regarding the app note you showed me, resistors, capa values changed, and not same ref of comparator (lower power consumption here). so it's very low power

[Cliff Karlsson]

Would it be possible to buy it pre-assembled soon?

[scalz]

Hi.

yes i'm preparing files for the fabhouse.
As you can see i've done a little update on my description, i'm focusing on my "work in progress" stuff to "released" at openhardware because i would like to release my others boards etc. and have my mind free for software. That will be hard for a pcb addict like me
I hope we'll get a reasonable price..This will be a project for contributing to Mysensors project

[NeverDie]

@scalz
Which enclosure do you recommend to go with it?

[scalz]

@NeverDie
3d printed box for a tailored stuff. I'll also upload .stl and design files. i'm looking at which parts can be "DP" on my BOM, for the pcba..

[ranseyer]

Hi,
is it possible to get the actual sketch ?

[goubs]

Hola,
Very nice, I order PCBs.
I have a question which size for the resonator 8Mhz X1 ?
By Advance thanks,

[scalz]

hi.
i've updated the bom. you can use CSTCE8M00G55-R0.
it's optional, you can omit it if you want, and use internal 8mhz

[goubs]

@scalz Thanks !

[tonnerre33]

Hi, which tool do you use for programming with your pogo pin avr isp ?

Why didn't use pogo pin for FTDI too ?

[scalz]

you can also use pogopin for ftdi, why not
for avrisp, i use an usbasp.

[tonnerre33]

@scalz Thx but how do you connect your USBASP on the pogo pins ?
I use an usbasp like this http://d1gsvnjtkwr6dd.cloudfront.net/large/AC-PG-USBASP_LRG.jpg but i don't see how to connect him on the pogo pins

[scalz]

nothing fancy..with dupont cable.
of course you won't connect the pogo directly on the usbasp.
make a small adapter. simple and cheap
Example with ftdi adapter

[mihai.aldea]

@scalz Awesome board, really. However, I'm a bit worried about its practical use. You see, the motion sensors are commonly placed near the ceiling or sometimes on the ceiling. This may induce a serious drift in the reported temperature. Ideally, a temperature sensor should be placed in the middle of the wall.
Some people would have the impression that they're wasting energy on heating during winter while others would boost their A/C units during the summer just to read they temperature they feel confortable with. This effect would be mitigate by either concealing the motion sensor at a proper height for temperature reading, or use a reference sensor for calibration and compensate the reported value of an improperly placed sensor, and that's assuming that the seasonal variation is linear.
Anyway, excellent SMD work, I'm still in the PTH ice age

[scalz]

@mihai-aldea
thx
of course i won't use temperature/hum sensor on the ceiling. Boards are small i can put them everywhere i want.
On my side, i just need one temp/hum/lum per room, and at least one PIR. This board needs to be well placed of course.
But if i need more PIR only, or temp/hum only... it's also possible. So i don't need to have a dedicated pcb per use. I stencil only what i need

[Sander Teunissen]

I guess ordering the pcb will only get me the pcb. I need to do the soldering etc myself ?
But I really wonder how to solder such a board seemingly being smd soldering. Are there any guides available for someone like me (pretty handy, but not experienced in this hardware stuff) ?
Thanks !

[NeverDie]

@Sander-Teunissen said:

I guess ordering the pcb will only get me the pcb. I need to do the soldering etc myself ?
But I really wonder how to solder such a board seemingly being smd soldering. Are there any guides available for someone like me (pretty handy, but not experienced in this hardware stuff) ?
Thanks !

@hek
Speaking of which, I thought there were going to be some mysensors manufacturering partners who would actually make this stuff, including the soldering. When is that going to happen?

[scalz]

i've been so busy during december, i'll be back for the new year

About pcba (assembling), it's already possible to use partners in your openhardware account. They may ask for more details if projects need it.

[NeverDie]

@scalz
Would they actually make a quantity 1?

[mihai.aldea]

@scalz said:

But if i need more PIR only, or temp/hum only... it's also possible. So i don't need to have a dedicated pcb per use. I stencil only what i need

Yeah, makes sense, a modular sensor PCB, a more advanced version than my Si7021 / DS18B20+ or PIR / door-window PCBs.

[hek]

@NeverDie

PCBWay have quoted a few fully assembled boards on openhardware.io but the prices is pretty high as they won't stock/produce larger batches.

It's a bit problematic to get low price at low volumes (and low financial commitment).

I suggest hardware contributors to setup some cooperation directly with the manufacturers. You should have a direct channel to them in the closed manufacturing forum here (accessible for all open hardware contributors).

[mihai.aldea]

@hek Have you considered using the Seeedstudio PCB assembly service? I haven't tried this service as all my PCB's are using old school PTH. But will try them at some point. It says that "Assembly Fee Starts from $25" but there's no mention whether it's a flat fee or it includes some components assembly. The pricing information is rather fuzzy and I wasn't needing the service for time being anyway so I didn't ask.

[hek]

Yes, Seeed Studio have access to quote assembled boards (since a couple of weeks back) on openhardware.io, but they haven't so far as it is a bit more complicated (time consuming) to get a accurate price.

@scalz and I have been in contact with Seed about this particular board. But we've not had time to follow up on some of their documentation requirements.

[Nca78]

@scalz said:

I stencil only what i need

I know it's a probably a bit late now, but have you considered making a separate board only for the PIR ?
Then the "main" board with other sensors would be (relatively) easy to solder and cheap to produce by PCBA, then people could order the PCBA of the PIR only separately if they need.

And it would be pretty useful for every other board maker on this forum also as a low power PIR is not a real option
I'm thinking about stealing your design to make a dedicated PIR child board, but I'm afraid my routing skills and electronic knowledge are not good enough yet to make a stable solution that will not be rigged by false detection problems

[scalz]

@Nca78
My best wishes for the new year

I designed this little pir sensor board last month with an optional lux sensor which i think is a nice sensor associated with a PIR. I will post files soon (I'm recovering today, phew!)
https://www.openhardware.io/view/292/Motion-And-Lux-Shield-V1
I also derivated it with MYSX connector, so it could be plugged on some new neat sensebender mk for instance

And i've asked a pcba for this sensor board, for curiosity. but i've been busy during december.. let's see what we'll get

But about MyMultisensors. I've designed V2 last month. I didn't need it..just because i wanted to try.
I've improved cost, changed PIR strategy, new mcu, still low power, and size is 30.5x25.5 ! with all sensors, and a new thing too. I stop talking.I should get the pcb soon and i'll show. .
Also, that will be a time2time work on the software part because of the mcu choice.

[dennis_henk]

Any news about the enclosure ? Or did i miss a comment

[particle]

Hello, this is really an excellent sensor!
I would like to buy the components for this project, but I do not know which to choose precisely: when I am looking for a capacitor 100n pack 0603 I have 16 V, 20 V, 15%, 20% etc ...
Do you have a list of references to help us?
Thanks !

[scalz]

I'll put stl for box soon, i need to check few things, and i'm busy.

As i've no time for the moment to upload a complete list with manufacturer parts etc.. it's a 3.3v board without regulator, so with passive >6V (for the 100uF for instance) you should be fine. So for others, 16v etc is enough. Rule i use in general, is 2x what my boards need

[particle]

Thanks, and is it OK if I buy 16V for the passive too ?
Like this one http://www.conrad.fr/ce/fr/product/457889/Condensateur-cramique-CMS-0603-Kemet-C0603C104K4RAC-01-F-16-V-10-X7R-1-pcs?ref=searchDetail for the 100nF for instance.

[Nca78]

Yes it's OK to buy 16V. And it should be a rule to buy x7r, so you should be good with those.
But for big values capacitors (used as power reserve), try to take as low voltage as possible on your circuit as leakage is proportionnal to rated voltage.

[particle]

Thank you so much, so I will buy 16V for 1u capacitor or more, and 6.3V for others.
And is there a rule for active ? (Watts, volts, amps...)

[Nca78]

@particle said:

Thank you so much, so I will buy 16V for 1u capacitor or more, and 6.3V for others.

No, it's the opposite
The higher the voltage rating, the more leakage/losses you will have. It's not important for small capacitors, but for reserve capacitors like 100µF it's better to take as low as possible, basically 2x the voltage used on your board.
Honestly it's not a big issue if you use 16V instead of 6V, but with a board as optimized for battery life as this one, it would be sad not to optimize the capacitors also

[particle]

OK understood, it's clear now !
And yes with the optimization work, I would like to pay tribute to him!
And is there a rule for active ? (Watts, volts, amps...)

[scalz]

Hey!

Sorry for being so late, too much pending projects

but here is how looks the custom box for my project. I need to polish a few things, especially sort of mounting plate, then i'll release my stl.

Box is 62x29x 11.6mm
No nails no screws.
i don't like to search my screwdriver or needing screws, or a shorting circuit screw.. So when i can i prefer snaps!

And in real

See you soon!

[tonnerre33]

@scalz Very good work dude ! What about de V2 ? because i want to build this awesome node but i have read somewhere, you are working on the V2

[scalz]

oki.
v2 won't be released soon (not this month sure) because i miss time, also it's not mysensors compatible yet. and not rfm69 too

[tonnerre33]

@scalz Oki. And for the nrf24 version ?

[Koresh]

Unfortunately this circuit and pcb contain a little mistake in reverse polarity protection module. Q1 must be connected as on the following diagram

So just reverse connections of drain and source of Q1, and the next version of your board will contain correct reverse polarity protection
PS
Otherwise your circuit will be powered through mosfet body diode (with a drop to ~0.6V of course) when polarity is crossed.

[scalz]

@Koresh thx for feedback Files are now updated and added a note

@tonnerre33 sorry for late reply. yes this will be nrf24 compatible, not rfm69. i'll try to show something soon, time does not help me!

[tonnerre33]

@scalz nrf24 for the V1 or V2? Because if V2 isn't mysensors compatible, i prefer use V1 but in nrf24 version

[Yeitso]

So there is no option yet to order complete boards with components in place from manufacturarer? Or am i not getting openhardware correct. Order 10 PCBs will just get me the pcb right?

[tonnerre33]

@Yeitso you are right, 10pcbs order will just give you the pcb

[tonnerre33]

I'm finalizing the nrf24 version because it's a nice board, that would be too bad for nrf24 user

Did you finish the nrf24 version @scalz ?

[scalz]

@tonnerre33 sorry for delay. yep, sure i finished it a while (rev 1.1 nrf), never ordered it, i use rfm for this node. but i'll upload this week oki

[tonnerre33]

@scalz Thx a lot ! I tried to replace the transmitter myself but the routing is too hard for me.

I'll try to check the schema before order the board

[Bigbug]

This looks like an awesome unit! Is there a way to buy this with components assembled? Looks like a lot of work to solder all those smds..

[pointbre]

I also wish I could buy assembled ones.

[tomtastic]

Likewise, to be able to buy assembled would be great

[alexsh1]

@scalz hi, excellent sensor! Do you know if the atmega328 memory is enough? You must have a large sketch for all sensors + signin

[scalz]

@alexsh1 thx
memory ok if sketch optimized (radio driver footprint too) and without much debug msg.
V2 will improve memory, cost and device size (will be 9in1 this time so i needed more mem) but for nrf24 networks only. i should release it soon if i can get rid of a little sw bug..

[mpp]

How long can you get these running on a single battery?

[bjornhallberg]

@scalz Would also be very interested in buying assembled modules. But why no more RFM69?

[alexsh1]

@mpp I suppose depends on which battery and what sensors - there are a few options here.

[alexsh1]

@scalz atmega328 is only good for simple sketches nowadays. I am struggling with a simple temp/hum/baro sensor with signing and debug as It runs on low memory and the sensor freezes after a few hours. I suppose we have to move to SAMD.
Do you have the STL file for the box please?

[Anticimex]

@alexsh1 regarding low memory problems, debug is intended for just that; debug. Once deployed, you can disable debug to ensure the longevity of your program. Probably the sketch eventually dies due to stack shortage.

[alexsh1]

@Anticimex Completely agree. Having said that I have a few nodes where I left debug purely for convenience. I do not want to re-flash the node to debug it in case need be. Right now I am in the process of changing the GW and may need to see node's debug.

[scalz]

@alexsh1
I agree with you about 328 and 8bits. And that's a while i've done a board for these
I won't use it in v2 though, tiny 9in1... not possible!
I also have custom SAMD boards, missing time to release those one too, but imho these mcu are not ultra low power (SAML is).

I'll publish stl this week..

[alexsh1]

@scalz ATSAM D21 is already compatible with MySensors, whereas ATSAM L21 may be in the pipeline. So for now, we all are stuck with SAMD.

Looking forward to your stl

[Konrad Walsh]

Phenomenal!

I have a stupid question.. clicking buy on the page.. what exactly does that buy you>?

[alexsh1]

@Konrad-Walsh You buy PCBs (10 0r 15 of them).

[Konrad Walsh]

I am sorry.. I should have been more clear...
When you say PCB.. Is that a fully assembled product with all the mentioned sensors? Or is it a board and you add sensors to it..

Please excuse my ignorance

[alexsh1]

@Konrad-Walsh Click on the link and see it yourself
PCB means a bare board and not a ready product. You have to procure parts and assemble it.

[Konrad Walsh]

@alexsh1 Thank you

[alexsh1]

@Konrad-Walsh said in MyMultisensors:

you

No problem.

@scalz There is a lot of interest from others to have an assembled sensor. Maybe as a suggestion, you would be interested talking to Itead or similar guys to get it arranged?
Personally, I am comfortable assembling an SMD board down to 0605 (though it is more difficult with the fan). My preference would be 0805 and up

[scalz]

thx for the interest though
for the moment, the quotation i got was not so great imho.. oki i'll try again with other fabhouse for this one as v2 will cover nrf only

[Nca78]

@scalz could you give an idea of the price ? I'm curious

[Carywin]

Where might I find the source code?

[alexsh1]

@Carywin a source code for what? There are many combinations of sensors.
I am sure @scalz can help

[bjornhallberg]

Still very much interested in buying the board with RFM69 footprint! Just saying!

[alexsh1]

@scalz do you mind me asking where you bought PIR lens, eeprom, and most important that fancy small antenna??? Thanks

[scalz]

sorry to be so quiet actually
I buy most of my ic at electronic suppliers like Mouser, Digikey, Arrow etc.

• the flash is AT25DF512C-MAHN-T . But for coincells, ota+rfm69 is a bit too much power hungry, imho..
• the small pcb antenna is ANT-868-USP but it was for fun, as a simple wire antenna works as well and is cheaper.
• PIR and PIR lens are from aliexpress or ebay. PIR is LHI968. And fresnel type is 8120.
  An example of link for the lens:
  http://www.ebay.com/itm/10-PIECE-White-Fresnel-8120-PIR-infrared-mini-sensor-lights-small-Lenses-/142190239995?hash=item211b32e0fb:g:WsAAAOSwEHpZJnuW

[alexsh1]

@scalz Thank you. I do shopping at those sites as well if I do a large order, but delivery charge is just killing if I need to order 1-3 items.

I am going to try 2450 with your board. It has 600mAh so I am hoping that using eeprom is fine with this coincell. Regarding 2032, I agree with you. I have a node, which consumes 5-6uA (with watchdog) and I had to disable the LED to use it with coincell. It just drains too much energy from a low capacity battery.

Yes, simple wire would work fine, but ANT-868-USP is just looking very tidy.

[alexsh1]

Just waiting for some components to finalise it

[scalz]

@alexsh1
nice assembly oshpark i guess ??
I agree too, for PIR use, CR2450 is a minimum.
Well, with my tinkering and some stock in case, i usually get very quickly the free shipping..
but you can find these flash at Arrow for instance, they just need 20€ min order.
I guess you already have those, but for example,, coincell holders etc are not really cheaper at aliexpress etc..
Time to do some stock for stuff you need perhaps

[alexsh1]

@scalz yes, it is oshpark- I usually use them as the quality is exceptional. And typically I only need 3-4 pcbs anyway.
Unfortunately, I do not have oven and do not use smd stencil, which means the process is very long and manual. A lot of hot air fan work under the magnifying glass, but given this is not a board with too many components, it works.

You should get some commission from Arrow. I have just placed my order for eeprom and some parts ;))

[Sergio Rius]

Good job! Looking forward for a assembled version for buying. (NRF, of course )

[Carywin]

@scalz I ordered some boards and components which are on the way, but I can't find the source code anywhere?

[alexsh1]

@scalz - I forgot to burn a bootloader onto a blank atmega328p tqfl. Can I burn it using your pogo pads? The only problem is that it my Adruino ISP is running at 5V. I do not have radio soldered. I am not going to damage anything connecting 5V to VCC3?

[scalz]

@alexsh1 pogopads are there for this. But SI7021, and others sensors are not 5v tolerant You'll need to use a regulator, and perhaps get a cheap 3v/5v programmer

@Carywin source code depends what you need. you can also use some examples from MySensors website. when i'll get more time (actually busy), i'll upload mine (need to check if it needs some polishing) or some examples.

[alexsh1]

@scalz I did manage with 5V. Just de-soldered SI7021 and uploaded DualOptiboot. Other components are 5V tolerant. Having said that, I recall I did upload a different bootloader at 5V to Sensebender Micro (without nrf24l01+) without damaging SI7021.

R22 has to be changed for 330 Ohm as 1.5k was way too dark and not visible. I like bright LEDs you know :-))

[scalz]

@alexsh1 i can see the led with 1k5 i'm using it only for debug on my side. But you're right, if you want more brightness. just be careful to not drain too much if you're using a coincell

[alexsh1]

@scalz I am with you on the battery. I completely switched it off on another node running on 2032. The node is reporting very hour and has got about 4uA consumption while sleeping. Probably will stay alive for a few years. However, when debugging, I like bright LEDs.

By the way, I tested the node - OPT3001 and SI7021 are working fine. Cannot test LHI968 as I still do not have some resistors. I am very satisfied. The only issue is that assembling the board is very tedious - but it is compensated by its size

[scalz]

@alexsh1 i'm very glad to hear that I'll try to upload an example for PIR pinchange with my helper lib for blindtime etc asap

[alexsh1]

@scalz I know you are currently developing a similar board on SAMD. Do you have any problems with atmega328p memory? Unfortunately, with signing and a few sensors, I'm running out of memory. On your node, I can have PIR, light, temp/hum and reed. I may struggle to combine all of them under 32kb with signing. Given that I have dualoptiboot (1.5k less) for OTA, it does not help either.

I can see your PIR setup is complex. What is it you are trying to achieve?

[scalz]

@alexsh1 my next board won't be for SAMD.
I need to check my code and what's the compil results, i don't remember exactly. but that was tight, 90% perhaps, i usually don't want to go above..
What do you mean by PIR setup is complex?

[alexsh1]

@scalz I can see you created MyPirHelper.h - not sure what your trying to achieve. Could you explain maybe a bit more?

[scalz]

@alexsh1 this is a lib for helping to use PIR, could be integrated in nodemanager though, but i generally prefer to keep hands on my code, also because C code is usually more memory optimized.
So this is for handling PIR like some controllers ic do, and pinchange, with weak functions for users functions etc.
How looks my flow:

/* *******************************************************************************************************************
 * PIR Sensor State Machine
 * 
 * Flow : sensitivity of pir sensor for noisy environment, limits tx, power saving..
 * 1) NODE_SETUP  : settle for PIR_SETTLE_TIME. Then 2)
 * 2) PIR_START   : Wait/sleep for the first pulse. Then 3)
 * 3) PIR_SCAN    : If One trigger, wait/sleep for PIR_DEFAULT_PULSES during the PIR_DEFAULT_WINDOWTIME. 
 *                  If so, the motion is validated. Then 4)
 *                  Else 2)
 * 4) PIR_CANCEL  : PIR is disabled for PIR_DEFAULT_CANCELTIME. After, this period it reports new changed state 
 *                  If LOW, then 5)
 *                  Else 4)
 * 5) PIR_IS_BLIND: Keep PIR sensor insensitive for PIR_DEFAULT_BLINDTIME before 2)
 * 
 * ******************************************************************************************************************** */

[alexsh1]

@scalz this is exactly what I do not understand. For me PIR is very simple - 1 or 0, HIGH or LOW. Why treating it differently? Maybe this is very Noobs, but this is how I treat my PIRs. I may introduce 10-30 secs delay for it to settle or 30sec sleep after it has been triggered (I do not want to have extra PIR messages to my GW and controller)

[scalz]

@alexsh1
sure PIR state is 0 or 1. I'm not changing anything to this. But you can fine tune this.

Do you mean you'll update each time there is a CHANGE ?? No intermediate state ??
If so, you'll waste a lot of power in useless radio TX, mcu processing, depending on days and traffic. and your batteries won't last for long!

When there are people for an hour in same room, do you update each time it triggers? That can be a lot of waste!
Also why not allowing a blindtime before redecting?
In days with lot of traffic at home for example. If you already know (or the controllers could adjust this dynamically too by custom commands) that a room will be busy. It's useless and will consumes power again, to send 0 if it will retrigger in just a few seconds.

So i've done sort of helper for creating intermediate states with timeouts and counters, with user defines etc.