Your browser does not seem to support JavaScript. As a result, your viewing experience will be diminished, and you may not be able to execute some actions.

Please download a browser that supports JavaScript, or enable it if it's disabled (i.e. NoScript).

Controller selection matrix

stefaanv last edited by
Not being very happy with Domoticz for various reasons, I'd like to chose a new controller.
However, I'm baffled by the number of them and by the amount of information available about them. It is not possible to read all the fora about all the controllers to figure out which one suits my personal needs best.

Would it be possible to have a page on the website with a matrix of properties of the controllers ? If the structure is made by the website people, the content can be filled in by the community.

Things I would be interested in are
- Functional features
- In what language the controller is written
- What API's are supported
- What scripting languages are supported
- Configuration user-friendliness
- Operation user-friendliness
- What OS-ses will it run on
- How wide and active is the supporting community
- Open-sourced or not
Reply Quote 0
1 Reply Last reply

1
Posts

939
Views

Suggested Topics

Contribution
General Discussion • • edoardoo

2

0
Votes

2
Posts

1246
Views

Hi @edoardoo I actually stumbled on your post a couple of weeks ago! Great writeup! We certainly need contributors. We need help with everything from the visualisation of sensordata in the frontend (considering using d3.js) to mqtt/node.js backend for receiving and processing sensor data. Please contact me or Johan for further discussions.
How can I choose a controller?
Controllers • • Feliw05

6

0
Votes

6
Posts

52
Views

@Feliw05 Selecting the "right" controller is of course a matter of opinion and depends how far you want to go into the homeautomation swamp . Normally i don't give advice like this (and i agree with @mfalkvidd - It's great to discuss with a friend!) but here a my 2 cents... I think i've tried them all in the table but i always return to 2 alternatives: homeassistant and domoticz. If you want the fastest way to get started with good trend charts i still think Domoticz is a great choise. The UI is not the prettiest (even if you can fix that by setting up custom dashboards like dashticz or so) but it's very functional and i think it has a good default setup with trendlines per sensor for day/month/year using highcharts. I have a few weather station systems running remote and then i use domoticz in docker containers on off site servers (but i've also had it running on rasberry PIs). Very light weight. Another alternative (maybe obvious) is homeassistant but it might be a bit overwelming since it's very flexible and can be run in so many different ways so you will find tons of howtos that doesn't work anymore. It has a very active community that isn't afraid of changing core concepts when needed which is both a strength and sometimes a weakness. For my personal homeautomation i have moved over completely to homeassistant and it's possible to create beautiful dashboards with little effort. Is has integrations for more or less everything and if not there will be soon or you can add it yourself. Example dashboard that i have in the house with car heating/charging, cameras and tons of sensors and zigbee devices. Actually used and appretiated by everyone in the house It's a bumpier ride at least at first but i think homeassistant wins in the long run - and it's open source!
Homie MySensors bridge Controller. For use in OpenHab 3 (and others)
Controllers • • David Dawson

4

3
Votes

4
Posts

70
Views

@David-Dawson great idea for that translation from homie to mysensors and back. but I think it would be a better approach, if mysensors would have the ability to "speak" homie-convention in MQTT optionally (e.g. #MY_GATEWAY_MQTT_HOMIE) that would eliminate the need of tweaking on an extra binding and let mysensors talk an IOT-standard
Does a Bluetooth controller/gateway exist?
Controllers • • Henmyg

5

0
Votes

5
Posts

61
Views

I have a similar project: For my fathers boat, I want to use a Nextion as a central informations display. I will use a asr6501 as self containing gateway/controller, so maybe we can exchange experiences.
Serial terminal
Controllers • serialgateway serial protocol • • dzairo

10

3
Votes

10
Posts

5175
Views

Hi dzairo, Just wondering if you still monitor this thread. If so would love to know how to install the ComPort component so I can modify and use your terminal code. For some reason I don't have any luck with adding it to the IDE. thanks, Andy.
PiHome relay set-up
Controllers • • A Former User

2

0
Votes

2
Posts

16
Views

Hi @Prohi, can you provide more information about your heating system? When searching about AirMax on the internet, I found this: https://www.airmaxhvac.com/ and this https://airmaxsc.com/ and this https://airmaxop.com/ and ... Is your heating system an hvac based system? With remote controls for each room?