Your browser does not seem to support JavaScript. As a result, your viewing experience will be diminished, and you may not be able to execute some actions.

Please download a browser that supports JavaScript, or enable it if it's disabled (i.e. NoScript).

Need feedback for correct direction

samjaynes last edited by

I have been researching home automation for several months now off and on (time permitting). I have two Arduino Unos, Raspberry Pi 2, and Raspberry Pi 3. I admit, I am a newbie to wireless RF communications, etc, but willing to learn.

I have been looking at this site, the Uber instructable that people have referred to, OpenHAB, etc. My initial scope is to monitor my garage door monitor, parking sensor, and hopefully some lights at some point. Then maybe into camera.

The issue I have is a lot of the articles I read are old, and I am wondering if I am exploring old technology when there could be easier implementations out there.

Would it be easier to buy an open source out of the box solution?
If DIY, what framework is preferred? Is a seperate gateway needed, or can that be house on the same OS board (For example, Pi with OpenHAB, Mosqitto, and NRF2401L etc)
If DIY, is NRF2401L+ still decent, or 8266 better? Suitable from garage to in the house?
If DIY, what is the preferred UI / app level? OpenHAB, etc
If DIY, your feedback...

Thanks again for your time, look forward to getting some current feedback
Reply Quote 0
1 Reply Last reply

1
Posts

415
Views

Suggested Topics

Update RF24 library to latest version
Bug Reports • • andriej

4

0
Votes

4
Posts

2570
Views

@andriej Hi, I had problem using the main branch mysensors/Raspberry, that because of the bit-field struct (header_s) in Sensor.h They will get packed in different order on the arduino compared to the RPi (at least with my compiler, gcc). In order to fix this I created the 1.4dev branch. It uses full bytes instead of the bit-fields, but you need (of cause) to compile both the sensors (arduino) and the gateway (RPi) using the 1.4dev branch. We need to fix this in the main branch later on (and use the same files as in mysensors/Arduino/libraries/MySensors)
Running out of nodeId's
General Discussion • mysensors • • NielBierman

8

3
Votes

8
Posts

47
Views

@TheoL Not only did I put in delays, too, but I put in delays that were based upon the ID (which was stored in NVRAM)! This helped. caveat: This is probably not accurate be helps to explain the challenges with a large network. My initial experience with Arduino/nRF24 was using the libraries from TMRh20. Those libraries allowed a node to be a repeater, but only for 6 nodes. The primary node 0, master, only allowed 6 nodes to connect to it. The nodes connected to it also allowed 6 nodes. Subsequent nodes had to go through one of these repeating nodes. But the depth was only 4 deep. The master assigned node IDs if the node didn't already have one; similar to a MAC address. The master also kept track of the addresses (ARP table?). Addresses were 4 octets (base in the form of D/C/B/A. A node connected directly to the master had an address of 0/0/0/a (where 0/0/0/0 was reserved for the master). A node connected through another node had an address of 0/0/b/a, and so forth. But what happens is that a parent node has to mange the data from all its child nodes and their child nodes and their child nodes. Thus a node would get so bogged down dealing with this traffic that it din't do its sensor task very well. It is my belief that MySensors either uses TMRh20's libraries or has developed some aspects based on his initial work. I see that that TMRh20 has a version 2 and I have not experimented with it. I did find that MySensors worked better than version 1. Thus, my curiosity. I am also duly impressed at the magnitude of hardware. Currently a nano like device from Aliexperss is US$2-3, nRF24 ~ US$1, power supply ~ US$1.50, power cord ?, case?, sensors!? While the hardware cost is daunting, even with a PCB it's a lot of work building those up. So, yeah, I'm impressed! -OSD
GatawayESP8266 - Compile error
General Discussion • gatawayesp8266 compile error • • skom

15

0
Votes

15
Posts

123
Views

@eiten Ran into the same error but of course the community is always at hand, ready to help! Great! I'm using MySensors 2.3.2 release version. Downgrading the ESP8266 board library to 2.7.4 as suggested by @OldSurferDude did the trick. I'm still clinging to MySensors. So simple and inexpensive to use! All sensors and other stuff connects over three MQTT GW in three locations back to my Home Assistant. PS: Get well soon! Regards, Gunnar
Old hardware migration
General Discussion • • dbemowsk

3

0
Votes

3
Posts

38
Views

@OldSurferDude My old 2.0 setup is with nRF24L01 radios. This is a link to the thread on some light switches that I designed and built. https://forum.mysensors.org/topic/7376/us-decora-wall-switch-continued/2 I am aware that you cannot have two MQTT gatways. When I designed my old setup I was not that familiar with MQTT so I never ended up implementing it. On the home assistant server that I have set up though, I have installed the MQTT broker on there so I should be able to comunicate with any MySensors stuff over MQTT in the future devices I make/set up. As I mentioned, I do have a Home Assistant box that I have started about 4 months ago and eventually want to migrate my Vera equipment to the HA box. As for the YAML and Python, I'll muddle my way through. used to program in PHP and have done enough on Arduino that I'm sure it won't hurt my brain too much.
How to great variables
General Discussion • arduino mycontroller.org variables • • wint0178

2

0
Votes

2
Posts

12
Views

Nice work so far @wint0178, great that you try expanding on the examples. Sorry for the late reply. If you look at https://github.com/mysensors/MySensorsArduinoExamples/blob/bba998bce09bc5139eb4ca7a05b0279f4083ff88/examples/PressureSensor/PressureSensor.ino#L90 you see where the existing child ids are defines. You just add another one for the gas sensor, with a unique number (incrementing by 1 is an easy way). Try that and report back on your result. If something is unclear, just post a followup.
What's a good power bank for use with IoT?
General Discussion • • NeverDie

20

1
Votes

20
Posts

179
Views

@OldSurferDude Thanks a very valued to know. I was wondering today why my (big) powerbanks fall down after short time. I have small 1 & 2-pieces powerbanks, they work very well. I use also BSM hw-168 or hw-107 for charging single 18650. Will try to use them outside also with small solarpanels.

Need feedback for correct direction

Suggested Topics

Update RF24 library to latest version
Bug Reports • • andriej

Running out of nodeId's
General Discussion • mysensors • • NielBierman

GatawayESP8266 - Compile error
General Discussion • gatawayesp8266 compile error • • skom

Old hardware migration
General Discussion • • dbemowsk

How to great variables
General Discussion • arduino mycontroller.org variables • • wint0178

What's a good power bank for use with IoT?
General Discussion • • NeverDie

0
Online

11.4k
Users

11.1k
Topics

112.7k
Posts

Need feedback for correct direction

Suggested Topics

Update RF24 library to latest version Bug Reports • • andriej

Running out of nodeId's General Discussion • mysensors • • NielBierman

GatawayESP8266 - Compile error General Discussion • gatawayesp8266 compile error • • skom

Old hardware migration General Discussion • • dbemowsk

How to great variables General Discussion • arduino mycontroller.org variables • • wint0178

What's a good power bank for use with IoT? General Discussion • • NeverDie

0Online

11.4kUsers

11.1kTopics

112.7kPosts

Update RF24 library to latest version
Bug Reports • • andriej

Running out of nodeId's
General Discussion • mysensors • • NielBierman

GatawayESP8266 - Compile error
General Discussion • gatawayesp8266 compile error • • skom

Old hardware migration
General Discussion • • dbemowsk

How to great variables
General Discussion • arduino mycontroller.org variables • • wint0178

What's a good power bank for use with IoT?
General Discussion • • NeverDie

0
Online

11.4k
Users

11.1k
Topics

112.7k
Posts