Fan control and feedback
I'm currently trying to add fan control and monitoring to one of my projects. I'm using a CPU PWM fan with 4 wires.
I can control the speed of the fan and read the rotation speed.
Currently the fan is registered as a S_DIMMER where it sends its speed back to the controller (domoticz) as a V_VAR1. The nice thing being that if later on I decide to add an additional fan I can use V_VAR2, etc... Unfortunately domoticz seems to ignore V_VAR messages, I can't find a way to graph them or set units.
As a workaround I don't see any sensor type that could be used to send RPMs either.
It's unclear to me if I should ask for another sensor type in MyS such as a RPM/frequency/speed one or if it would be better to keep V_VAR and ask for a way to graph them in the controller.
Is there an official position on this kind of issue, being compatible with all controllers?
@emc2 As the V_VAR types have no specific meaning Domoticz cannot handle them in a structured way.
For a fan I would choose a PERCENTAGE type and let Domoticz treat it as (the new) Selector switch. You can even choose a fan icon for it.
V_VAR should be used for (temporary) storage of variables only.
Thanks for the heads up. The selector is an option, but the sliding ruler of the domoticz interface is actually more suitable in my current use. I was looking at the S_HVAC that could have worked too, but the slider is nicer for fine tuning. I wish I could have a fan icon with the Dimmer option in domoticz. Control by itself is working fine.
I guess V_VAR is not adapted for that then. Too bad.
I'm thinking of trying a S_DISTANCE using V_UNIT_PREFIX (RPM) and V_DISTANCE to send the values. It's kind of dirty but well.
Maybe using V_UNIT_PREFIX with a S_CUSTOM sensor and sending V_LEVEL for the values is what seems almost the most intuitive, but it seems we can't do that.
Any idea of a workaround solution using current sensors that could be accepted by the controller?
drock1985 last edited by
What about media player and volume to control fan speed?
@emc2 No support for S_CUSTOM and the Prefix types in Domoticz. You need to stick to the known datatypes in Domoticz
@AWI I discovered it the hard way tonight. Lot of "Unknown sensor type" in my domoticz log.
I have it working by declaring it as a distance, pressure etc. It's really dirty but at least for know I can track my RPMs. I guess I will try to poke around on the domoticz forums this week end to see if there is something cooking on their side.